文献速递传染病防控与疫情报告卫生政策与健康促进

评估生物安全与防控措施以预防欧洲新发跨界动物疫病传入并限制其传播:一项专家调查

Assessment of biosecurity and control measures to prevent incursion and to limit spread of emerging transboundary animal diseases in Europe: An expert survey.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2017-07-24

本研究旨在评估意大利、瑞士和英国专家对预防狂犬病、蓝舌病和经典猪瘟传入与传播的所选生物安全措施的重要性、有效性、可行性、成本和可接受性的看法。通过问卷对项目组确定的最相关措施进行专家知识启发,每国3名专家(每种病1名)完成问卷,平均应答率分别为经典猪瘟73%、蓝舌病100%、狂犬病99%。「活体动物贸易追溯系统」在所有疾病中被强调为非常相关,「疑似或确诊后限制区」的实施也被评为相关措施,尤其对经典猪瘟。

要点

  • 「活体动物贸易追溯系统」在所有疾病中被强调为非常相关。
  • 「疑似或确诊后限制区」被评为相关措施,尤其对经典猪瘟。
  • 狂犬病专家中与「人兽共患病风险」相关的措施评分较高,支持One Health方法。

核心结论

  • 「活体动物贸易追溯系统」在所有疾病中被强调为非常相关。
  • 「疑似或确诊后限制区」的实施也被评为相关措施,尤其对经典猪瘟。
  • 狂犬病专家中与「人兽共患病风险」相关的措施评分较高,支持One Health方法的理念。

研究设计与样本

  • 由项目组确定最相关措施后,通过问卷实施专家知识启发。
  • 意大利、瑞士和英国每国3名专家完成问卷,每种疾病1名专家。
  • 完成初步描述性分析后,进行加权中位数、Spearman秩相关检验、Wilcoxon比较检验和措施排序等统计计算。

主要发现

  • 经典猪瘟、蓝舌病和狂犬病的平均应答率分别为73%、100%和99%。
  • 总体发现成本与其他标准之间相关性较小。
  • 专家间分歧涉及三种病原体的43项措施:有争议的措施为「野猪经典猪瘟状态控制」、「节肢动物媒介控制」和「家养动物狂犬病疫苗接种」。

临床怎么用

  • 面对预算限制,决策者需要优先排序行动并做出有效的预防选择。
  • 本研究旨在提供反思要素并为优先级设定提供信息。
  • 结果可通过实施类似调查或直接利用本研究已收集的知识来应用。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Decision-makers and risk managers are often called upon to prioritise on and recommend suitable measures to prevent the risk of introduction and spread of pathogens. The main objective of this study was to assess the perceptions of experts in Italy, Switzerland and the United Kingdom concerning the importance, effectiveness, feasibility, costs and acceptability of selected biosecurity measures to prevent the introduction and limit the spread of rabies, blue tongue (BT) and classical swine fever (CSF). After identifying the most relevant measures by the project team, an expert knowledge elicitation was implemented through a questionnaire. After preliminary descriptive analyses, a number of statistical calculations were performed such as weighted medians, Spearman rank correlation tests, Wilcoxon comparison tests and ranking of measures. Three experts from each country completed the questionnaires, one expert for each disease. The mean answer rates for CSF, BT and rabies were 73%, 100% and 99% respectively. "Tracing system for live animal trade" was highlighted as very relevant in all diseases. The implementation of a "restriction zone after a suspicion or confirmation" was also rated as a relevant measure, especially for CSF. We identified generally a small correlation between costs and the other criteria. Among the rabies experts, measures related to "zoonotic risk" were rated highly, supporting the idea of a One Health approach. Disagreement among experts concerned 43 measures for the three pathogens: the debated measures were "control of the wildlife CSF status", "arthropod-vector control" and "rabies vaccination for domestic animals". Facing budget restriction, decision-makers need to prioritise their actions and make efficient prevention choices. With this study, we aimed to provide elements for reflection and to inform priority setting. The results can be applied through the implementation of similar surveys or directly from the knowledge already gathered in this study.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Léger A, De Nardi M, Simons R, et al. Assessment of biosecurity and control measures to prevent incursion and to limit spread of emerging transboundary animal diseases in Europe: An expert survey. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28750852. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.07.034

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。