荷兰百日咳相关住院和死亡被严重低估:一项捕获-再捕获分析
该研究采用捕获-再捕获分析评估荷兰百日咳住院和死亡报告完整性(CoR)。<2岁婴儿住院估计1446例,CoR为52%–61%;≥2岁住院估计1512例,CoR为16.5%–22%。<2岁死亡估计16例,CoR为50%–81%;≥2岁死亡估计26例,CoR为8%–31%,显示显著低估。
要点
- 百日咳住院和死亡报告完整性低,存在严重低估。
- <2岁婴儿住院CoR为52%–61%,≥2岁住院CoR为16.5%–22%。
- <2岁死亡CoR为50%–81%,≥2岁死亡CoR为8%–31%。
核心结论
- 荷兰百日咳相关住院和死亡被严重低估,评估当前和未来免疫规划时需考虑此低估。
研究设计与样本
- 采用捕获-再捕获分析估计报告完整性(CoR);住院数据(2007–2014年)来自国家医院护理登记,与法定传染病病例登记(通知)匹配;死亡数据(1996–2014年)来自荷兰统计局死亡登记,与通知匹配;病例按<2岁和≥2岁分别分析;使用Chao估计量估计总人群。
主要发现
- 严格匹配标准下,<2岁住院:医院数据876例与通知757例中匹配461例,估计住院婴儿总数1446例,CoR为52%–61%。
- ≥2岁住院:医院数据246例与通知264例中匹配43例,估计总数1512例,CoR为16.5%–22%。
- <2岁死亡:死亡登记13例与通知8例中重叠7例,估计总数16例,两来源CoR为50%–81%。
- ≥2岁死亡:死亡登记2例与通知8例无重叠,估计总数26例,CoR为8%–31%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OJECTIVE: Despite vaccination, pertussis has remained endemic, sometimes leading to severe disease. We aimed to quantify the completeness of reporting (CoR) of pertussis hospitalizations and deaths in the Netherlands. STUDY DESIGN: CoR was estimated using capture-recapture analyses. Hospitalizations (2007-2014) from the National Registration Hospital Care (hospital data) were matched to the notifiable Infectious Disease case registry (notifications) providing (month and) year of birth, gender and postal code. Deaths (1996-2014) from Statistics Netherlands (death registry) were matched to notifications using gender, age, year of death and notification date. Cases <2years (y) and ≥2y were analysed separately. Chao's estimator estimated the total population, which was used to calculate CoR. RESULTS: Using strict matching criteria, we found 461 matches among 876 (hospital data) and 757 (notifications) hospitalizations <2y. The population estimate of hospitalized infants was 1446, resulting in CoR between 52% and 61%. For hospitalizations ≥2y (246; hospital data and 264; notifications) 43 matches were found, with a population estimate of 1512 and CoR between 16.5% and 22%. Among thirteen (death registry) and eight (notifications) deaths <2y, seven cases overlapped. The population estimate was 16. CoR of the two sources was 50-81%. With two (death registry) and eight (notifications) deaths ≥2y without overlap, the population estimate was 26 and CoR 8-31%. CONCLUSION: Results showed substantial underestimation of pertussis hospitalizations and deaths. This has to be taken into account in evaluation of current and future immunization programs.
引用
- van der Maas NAT, Hoes J, Sanders EAM, et al. Severe underestimation of pertussis related hospitalizations and deaths in the Netherlands: A capture-recapture analysis. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28651837. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.06.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。