通过图形传达传染病患病率:一项国际调查的结果
该国际在线调查将16510名来自11个国家的成年人随机分配阅读配有热力图、点图或象形趋势线之一的模拟新闻文章,比较三种图形对接种意愿、风险感知和知识的影响。结果显示热力图在增加接种兴趣、感知疾病风险和获取更多信息兴趣方面优于象形趋势线且与点图无差异,热力图和象形趋势线在传达知识上均优于点图,热力图是唯一在所有结局上均优的图形。
要点
- 热力图和象形趋势线比点图获得更积极的评价。
- 热力图在增加接种兴趣、感知风险和获取更多信息兴趣上优于象形趋势线,与点图无差异。
- 热力图和象形趋势线在传达知识上均优于点图,热力图是唯一在所有结局上均优的图形。
核心结论
- 热力图是促进对传染病兴趣和关注的可行选择。
研究设计与样本
- 国际在线调查,参与者被随机分配阅读配有热力图、点图或象形趋势线之一的模拟新闻文章,三种图形传达相同的假设流感暴发传播信息。
- 参与者为11个国家按年龄和性别分层随机抽样的16510名成年人。
主要发现
- 热力图和象形趋势线比点图获得更积极的评价。
- 热力图在增加接种兴趣、感知疾病风险和获取更多信息兴趣上优于象形趋势线,与点图无差异。
- 热力图和象形趋势线在传达知识上均优于点图。
- 热力图是唯一在所有结局上均优的图形。
局限性
- 结果基于假设情景。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Graphics are increasingly used to represent the spread of infectious diseases (e.g., influenza, Zika, Ebola); however, the impact of using graphics to adequately inform the general population is unknown. OBJECTIVE: To examine whether three ways of visually presenting data (heat map, dot map, or picto-trendline)-all depicting the same information regarding the spread of a hypothetical outbreak of influenza-influence intent to vaccinate, risk perception, and knowledge. DESIGN: Survey with participants randomized to receive a simulated news article accompanied by one of the three graphics that communicated prevalence of influenza and number of influenza-related deaths. SETTING: International online survey. PARTICIPANTS: 16,510 adults living in 11 countries selected using stratified random sampling based on age and gender. MEASUREMENTS: After reading the article and viewing the presented graphic, participants completed a survey that measured interest in vaccination, perceived risk of contracting disease, knowledge gained, interest in additional information about the disease, and perception of the graphic. RESULTS: Heat maps and picto-trendlines were evaluated more positively than dot maps. Heat maps were more effective than picto-trendlines and no different from dot maps at increasing interest in vaccination, perceived risk of contracting disease, and interest in additional information about the disease. Heat maps and picto-trendlines were more successful at conveying knowledge than dot maps. Overall, heat maps were the only graphic to be superior in every outcome. LIMITATIONS: Results are based on a hypothetical scenario. CONCLUSION: Heat maps are a viable option to promote interest in and concern about infectious diseases.
引用
- Fagerlin A, Valley TS, Scherer AM, et al. Communicating infectious disease prevalence through graphics: Results from an international survey. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28647168. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.05.048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。