太阳能冰箱何时比并网冰箱成本更低:一项模拟建模研究
研究利用HERMES生成的莫桑比克常规免疫供应链计算模型,模拟在供应链不同环节、不同情境下使用太阳能冰箱与电网供电冰箱的成本。结果显示,在当前价格溢价下,太阳能冰箱在地区级年成本比电网冰箱高132%,在卫生机构级高241%;但当特定频率和时长的停电发生时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。研究支持WHO和Gavi指南,并指出在停电较少时太阳能冰箱也可能节省每剂接种总成本。
要点
- 当前价格下,太阳能冰箱年成本在地区级高132%,在卫生机构级高241%。
- 地区级或卫生机构级每年发生1天停电超过5次时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。
- 地区级每年2天停电超过3次或卫生机构级超过2次时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。
核心结论
- 研究支持WHO和Gavi指南,太阳能冰箱在停电频率较低时也可能在每剂接种总成本上比电网冰箱节省。
研究设计与样本
- 使用HERMES生成的莫桑比克常规免疫供应链计算模型,模拟供应链不同地点、不同情况下太阳能冰箱与电网供电冰箱的使用。
主要发现
- 当前价格溢价下,每台太阳能冰箱年成本在地区级比每台电网冰箱高132%,在卫生机构级高241%。
- 地区级或卫生机构级每年发生1天停电超过5次时,太阳能冰箱比电网冰箱节省成本,即使电网冰箱的保温时间超过停电时长。
- 地区级每年2天停电超过3次或卫生机构级超过2次时,太阳能冰箱也可节省成本。
- 太阳能冰箱年成本降至比电网冰箱高75%时,地区级或卫生机构级每年1天停电超过1次,或地区级每年2天停电超过1次、卫生机构级每年2天停电超过1次时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。
关键数值与推荐
- Gavi建议在每天电力不足8小时的地区使用太阳能冰箱储存疫苗,WHO指南更为保守。
- 当前价格下,太阳能冰箱年成本在地区级比电网冰箱高132%,在卫生机构级高241%。
- 地区级或卫生机构级每年1天停电超过5次时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。
- 地区级每年2天停电超过3次或卫生机构级超过2次时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。
- 太阳能冰箱价格降至比电网冰箱高75%时,地区级或卫生机构级每年1天停电超过1次,或地区级每年2天停电超过1次、卫生机构级每年2天停电超过1次时,太阳能冰箱可节省成本。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Gavi recommends solar refrigerators for vaccine storage in areas with less than eight hours of electricity per day, and WHO guidelines are more conservative. The question remains: Can solar refrigerators provide value where electrical outages are less frequent? METHODS: Using a HERMES-generated computational model of the Mozambique routine immunization supply chain, we simulated the use of solar versus electric mains-powered refrigerators (hereafter referred to as "electric refrigerators") at different locations in the supply chain under various circumstances. RESULTS: At their current price premium, the annual cost of each solar refrigerator is 132% more than each electric refrigerator at the district level and 241% more at health facilities. Solar refrigerators provided savings over electric refrigerators when one-day electrical outages occurred more than five times per year at either the district level or the health facilities, even when the electric refrigerator holdover time exceeded the duration of the outage. Two-day outages occurring more than three times per year at the district level or more than twice per year at the health facilities also caused solar refrigerators to be cost saving. Lowering the annual cost of a solar refrigerator to 75% more than an electric refrigerator allowed solar refrigerators to be cost saving at either level when one-day outages occurred more than once per year, or when two-day outages occurred more than once per year at the district level or even once per year at the health facilities. CONCLUSION: Our study supports WHO and Gavi guidelines. In fact, solar refrigerators may provide savings in total cost per dose administered over electrical refrigerators when electrical outages are less frequent. Our study identified the frequency and duration at which electrical outages need to occur for solar refrigerators to provide savings in total cost per dose administered over electric refrigerators at different solar refrigerator prices.
引用
- Haidari LA, Brown ST, Wedlock P, et al. When are solar refrigerators less costly than on-grid refrigerators: A simulation modeling study. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28364935. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2016.11.103
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。