改善成人免疫公平性:已发表研究文献与现有资源指向何处?
本文基于美国疾病控制与预防中心已开展的文献综述,检索同行评议文献中讨论减少成人免疫差异的干预措施或提供差异原因与关联的文章,并通过网络检索识别支持提高成人免疫接种率的工具与资源,检索均限定于流感、肺炎球菌、乙型肝炎、Tdap和/或带状疱疹疫苗接种。多数文章描述成人免疫差异,部分讨论减少差异的策略,包括基于实践的改变、沟通与健康素养方法以及与社区组织合作;识别的资源多为面向患者的情况说明书和讲义及面向提供者的期刊文章,多数资源涉及流感疫苗接种,西班牙语是除英语外最普遍的语言。更多评估需评估材料的健康素养水平。作者结论为需要更多研究识别减少成人免疫差异的有效方法,需要更多资源支持提供者,并建议识别高绩效者的最佳实践、进一步审查现有资源的适宜性和有用性、确定应优先解决的差距。
要点
- 多数文献描述成人免疫差异,部分讨论减少差异的策略。
- 减少差异策略包括基于实践的改变、沟通与健康素养方法、与社区组织合作。
- 识别的资源多为患者情况说明书和讲义及提供者期刊文章,多数涉及流感疫苗。
核心结论
- 需要更多研究识别减少成人免疫差异的有效方法,需要更多资源支持提供者。
- 作者建议识别高绩效者的最佳实践、进一步审查现有资源的适宜性和有用性、确定应优先解决的差距。
研究设计与样本
- 基于美国疾病控制与预防中心已开展的文献综述,检索同行评议文献识别讨论减少成人免疫差异的干预措施或提供差异原因与关联的文章。
- 通过网络检索识别支持提高成人免疫接种率的工具与资源。
- 两项检索均限定于流感、肺炎球菌、乙型肝炎、Tdap和/或带状疱疹疫苗接种。
主要发现
- 多数文章描述成人免疫差异,部分讨论减少差异的策略,包括基于实践的改变、沟通与健康素养方法以及与社区组织合作。
- 识别的资源多为面向患者的情况说明书和讲义及面向提供者的期刊文章。
- 多数资源涉及流感疫苗接种,西班牙语是除英语外最普遍的语言。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议识别高绩效者的最佳实践、进一步审查现有资源的适宜性和有用性、确定应优先解决的差距。
- 更多评估需评估材料的健康素养水平。
局限性
- 更多评估需评估材料的健康素养水平。
- 需要更多研究识别减少成人免疫差异的有效方法,需要更多资源支持提供者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Evidence suggests that disparities in adult immunization (AI) rates are growing. Providers need adequate patient resources and information about successful interventions to help them engage in effective practices to reduce AI disparities. The primary purposes of this paper were to review and summarize the evidence base regarding interventions to reduce AI disparities and to scan for relevant resources that could support providers in their AI efforts to specifically target disparities. First, building on a literature review conducted by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, we searched the peer-reviewed literature to identify articles that either discussed interventions to reduce AI disparities or provided reasons and associations for disparities. We scanned the articles and conducted an internet search to identify tools and resources to support efforts to improve AI rates. We limited both searches to resources that addressed influenza, pneumococcal, hepatitis B, Tdap, and/or herpes zoster vaccinations. We found that most articles characterized AI disparities, but several discussed strategies for reducing AI disparities, including practice-based changes, communication and health literacy approaches, and partnering with community-based organizations. The resources we identified were largely fact sheets and handouts for patients and journal articles for providers. Most resources pertain to influenza vaccination and Spanish was the most prevalent language after English. More evaluation is needed to assess the health literacy levels of the materials. We conclude that additional research is needed to identify effective ways to reduce AI disparities and more resources are needed to support providers in their efforts. We recommend identifying best practices of high performers, further reviewing the appropriateness and usefulness of available resources, and prioritizing which gaps should be addressed.
引用
- Prins W, Butcher E, Hall LL, et al. Improving adult immunization equity: Where do the published research literature and existing resources lead? Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28455174. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.02.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。