流感疫苗接种反应:评估医务人员重复接种的影响
该前瞻性血清学调查在三级转诊医院比较多次接种(高接种组)与较少接种(低接种组)医务人员接种2015年南半球三价流感疫苗后的抗体反应。202名医务人员入组,182名完成研究(高接种组143人,低接种组39人)。两组接种后几何平均滴度均升高且低接种组增幅更大,高接种组与低接种组接种后血清阳性率均保持高位;低接种组对疫苗H3N2成分的倍数上升最高。作者认为结果提示高接种医务人员血清学反应可能减弱,但需更大样本及更多未接种和仅接种一次人群的研究确认或反驳后再做政策改变。
要点
- 182名完成研究的医务人员中,高接种组143人、低接种组39人。
- 两组接种后几何平均滴度均升高,低接种组增幅更大。
- 低接种组对疫苗H3N2成分的倍数上升最高。
核心结论
- 高接种组与低接种组接种后均出现保护性抗体滴度。
- 本研究结果提示高接种医务人员血清学反应可能减弱。
- 作者认为需更大样本及更多未接种和仅接种一次人群的研究确认或反驳后再做政策改变。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性血清学调查,在三级转诊医院纳入医务人员。
- 医务人员接种2015年南半球三价流感疫苗。
- 202名医务人员入组,182名完成研究(高接种组143人,低接种组39人)。
- 采用血凝抑制试验测定接种前、接种后21-28天及接种后6个月的流感抗体滴度。
主要发现
- 高接种组与低接种组接种后几何平均滴度均升高,低接种组增幅更大。
- 高接种组与低接种组接种后血清阳性率均保持高位。
- 低接种组对疫苗H3N2成分的倍数上升最高。
局限性
- 作者认为需更大样本及更多未接种和仅接种一次人群的研究确认或反驳这些发现后再做政策改变。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the antibody response to influenza between health care workers (HCWs) who have received multiple vaccinations (high vaccination group) and those who have received fewer vaccinations (low vaccination group). DESIGN: Prospective serosurvey. SETTING: Tertiary referral hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Healthcare workers. METHODS: Healthcare workers were vaccinated with the 2015 southern hemisphere trivalent influenza vaccine. Influenza antibody titres were measured pre-vaccination, 21-28days post-vaccination and 6months post-vaccination. Antibody titres were measured using the haemagglutination inhibition assay. Levels of seropositivity and estimated geometric mean titres were calculated. RESULTS: Of the 202 HCWs enrolled, 182 completed the study (143 high vaccination and 39 low vaccination). Both vaccination groups demonstrated increases in post-vaccination geometric mean titres, with greater gains in the low vaccination group. Seropositivity remained high in both high and low vaccination groups post-vaccination. The highest fold rise was observed among HCWs in the low vaccination group against the H3N2 component of the vaccine. CONCLUSIONS: Both high and low vaccination groups in our study demonstrated protective antibody titres post-vaccination. The findings from the current study are suggestive of decreased serological response among highly vaccinated HCWs. More studies with larger sample sizes and a greater number of people in the vaccine-naïve and once-vaccinated groups are required to confirm or refute these findings before making any policy changes.
引用
- Leung VKY, Carolan LA, Worth LJ, et al. Influenza vaccination responses: Evaluating impact of repeat vaccination among health care workers. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28385605. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.03.063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。