量化人群对严重但罕见疾病疫苗接种的偏好:2016年法国大学生联合分析
2016年3月至5月在法国雷恩对18-24岁大学生(N=775)开展电子邮件调查,用联合分析评估四种属性对假设性罕见严重疾病疫苗接种接受度的影响。参与者平均接受52%的情景,所有属性均显著影响接受度,疫情形势、社区90%覆盖率和疾病消除潜力正向影响最大,争议的负向影响大于确认的严重不良事件风险。对卫生当局的信任和疫苗认知本身也强烈影响接受度。
要点
- 疫情形势(OR 3.81)、社区90%覆盖率(OR 3.64)和疾病消除潜力(OR 2.87)正向影响接种接受度。
- 争议的负向影响(OR 0.05)大于确认的严重不良事件风险(OR 0.22)。
- 对卫生当局的信任和疫苗认知强烈影响接受度,但偏好权重不变。
核心结论
- 在年轻成人中,间接保护潜力以及社区覆盖率和潜在副作用的真实信息正向影响理论疫苗接受度。
- 应开展联合分析以理解特定疫苗接种规划中的疫苗犹豫。
研究设计与样本
- 2016年3月至5月在法国雷恩对18-24岁大学生(N=775)开展电子邮件调查。
- 参与者在24个假设情景中对是否立即接种疫苗做出选择,情景包含疫情形势、不良事件、疫苗接种覆盖率信息和间接保护潜力四个属性。
- 数据采用随机效应估计logit模型分析。
主要发现
- 参与者平均接受52%的情景,所有属性均显著影响接种接受度。
- 疫情形势(OR 3.81,95%CI 3.46-4.19)、社区90%覆盖率(OR 3.64,95%CI 3.15-4.20)和疾病消除潜力(OR 2.87,95%CI 2.53-3.26)的正向效应最高。
- 关于「覆盖率不足」的信息具有劝阻作用(与无朋友接种相比:OR 0.65,95%CI 0.56-0.75)。
- 争议的负向影响显著大于确认的严重不良事件风险(OR 0.05 vs. OR 0.22)。
- 在纳入参与者特征的模型中,偏好权重不变,而对卫生当局的信任和疫苗认知本身强烈影响接受度。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Several concepts are available to explain vaccine decision making by individual and inter-individual factors, including risk perception, social conformism and altruism. However, only a few studies have quantified the weight of these determinants in vaccine acceptance. Using a conjoint analysis tool, we aimed at eliciting preferences in a student population regarding vaccination against a rare, severe and rapidly evolving hypothetical disease, similar to meningococcal serogroup C meningitis or measles. METHODS: During March-May 2016, we conducted an emailing survey among university students aged 18-24years (N=775) in Rennes, France. Participants were asked to decide for or against immediate vaccination in 24 hypothetical scenarios, containing various levels of four attributes: epidemic situation, adverse events, information on vaccination coverage, and potential for indirect protection. Data were analysed using random effect estimator logit models. RESULTS: Participants accepted on average 52% of scenarios and all attributes significantly impacted vaccination acceptance. The highest positive effects were seen with an epidemic situation (OR 3.81, 95%-CI 3.46-4.19), 90% coverage in the community (3.64, 3.15-4.20) and potential for disease elimination from the community (2.87, 2.53-3.26). Information on "insufficient coverage" was dissuasive (vs. none of friends vaccinated: 0.65, 0.56-0.75). Controversy had a significantly greater negative effect than a confirmed risk of severe adverse events (OR 0.05 vs. 0.22). In models including participant characteristics, preference weights were unchanged, while trust in health authorities and vaccination perceptions strongly influenced acceptance themselves. The greatest significant variation of preference weights between subgroups was observed with controversy among students using alternative medicine daily (OR 0.28) and among students relying on scientific vaccine information (OR 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Among young adults, potential for indirect protection and factual information on coverage in the community and potential side effects positively impact theoretical vaccine acceptance. Conjoint analyses should be conducted to understand vaccine hesitancy in specific vaccination programs.
引用
- Seanehia J, Treibich C, Holmberg C, et al. Quantifying population preferences around vaccination against severe but rare diseases: A conjoint analysis among French university students, 2016. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28408120. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.03.086
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。