文献速递卫生政策与健康促进

健康公平与将人群健康原因强行加总为100%的谬误

Health Equity and the Fallacy of Treating Causes of Population Health as if They Sum to 100.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Public Health · 2017-01-01

本文分析人群健康研究中将健康原因错误地强制加总为100%的现象,回顾了Doll和Peto 1981年关于癌症原因的研究、2015年《科学》杂志关于三分之二癌症归因于偶然的论文以及“县健康排名与路线图”网站模型等案例,指出该谬误源于将因果关系解析为先天与后天的二元对立,并提出更好的风险统计与健康公平监测方法。

要点

  • 将人群健康原因强制加总为100%的谬误已存在80年,但仍在高影响力研究中反复出现。
  • “县健康排名与路线图”模型将健康原因加总为100%:物理环境10%、社会经济因素40%、临床照护20%、健康行为30%。
  • 该谬误的根源是将因果关系简单解析为先天与后天的二元对立,需采用更好的风险统计方法。

核心结论

  • 将人群健康原因强制加总为100%的谬误源于将因果关系解析为先天与后天的二元对立,这种观点仍占主导但存在严重缺陷,需要更好的风险统计与健康公平监测方法。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为对人群健康研究中将原因加总为100%的谬误进行批判性分析的文章,回顾了多个高影响力案例及相关历史辩论。

主要发现

  • Doll和Peto 1981年关于癌症原因的研究及其当前解读被作为高影响力案例回顾。
  • 2015年《科学》杂志高关注度文章声称三分之二的癌症可归因于偶然。
  • “县健康排名与路线图”网站模型将健康原因加总为100%:物理环境10%、社会经济因素40%、临床照护20%、健康行为30%。
  • 对上述工作及更早历史辩论的分析表明,强制原因加总为100%的谬误背后是先天与后天二元对立的因果解析观。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Numerous examples exist in population health of work that erroneously forces the causes of health to sum to 100%. This is surprising. Clear refutations of this error extend back 80 years. Because public health analysis, action, and allocation of resources are ill served by faulty methods, I consider why this error persists. I first review several high-profile examples, including Doll and Peto's 1981 opus on the causes of cancer and its current interpretations; a 2015 high-publicity article in Science claiming that two thirds of cancer is attributable to chance; and the influential Web site "County Health Rankings & Roadmaps: Building a Culture of Health, County by County," whose model sums causes of health to equal 100%: physical environment (10%), social and economic factors (40%), clinical care (20%), and health behaviors (30%). Critical analysis of these works and earlier historical debates reveals that underlying the error of forcing causes of health to sum to 100% is the still dominant but deeply flawed view that causation can be parsed as nature versus nurture. Better approaches exist for tallying risk and monitoring efforts to reach health equity.

来源:Am J Public Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Krieger N. Health Equity and the Fallacy of Treating Causes of Population Health as if They Sum to 100. Am J Public Health. 2017. PMID: 28272952. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2017.303655

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。