季节性疫苗接种是否影响老年人流感临床表现?法国门诊2003-2014年横断面分析
在法国全国哨点全科医生监测系统中纳入2277名65岁及以上因急性呼吸道感染就诊者(其中1293人接种流感疫苗,占56.8%),2003-2014年间采集鼻咽拭子检测呼吸道病毒并比较接种与未接种流感患者的症状。675例(29.6%)流感阳性,接种者最高体温略低、肌痛、寒战和头痛较少,调整后仅头痛差异有统计学意义(OR 0.69,95%CI 0.48-0.98)。结论认为疫苗与老年人流感临床表现较轻呈适度关联。
要点
- 2277名65岁及以上急性呼吸道感染就诊者中1293人(56.8%)接种流感疫苗,675例(29.6%)流感阳性。
- 接种者较未接种流感患者最高体温略低,肌痛、寒战和头痛较少见。
- 调整年龄组、病毒(亚)型和季节后仅头痛差异有统计学意义(OR 0.69,95%CI 0.48-0.98)。
核心结论
- 疫苗与老年人流感临床表现较轻呈适度关联,研究结果强调需要提供更好保护效果的流感疫苗。
研究设计与样本
- 基于法国全国哨点全科医生监测系统的横断面分析,纳入2003-2014年2277名65岁及以上因急性呼吸道感染就诊者。
主要发现
- 675例急性呼吸道感染患者(29.6%)流感检测阳性,A(H3)病毒占多数(55.1%),其次为乙型流感(22.9%)、A未分亚型(11.7%)和A(H1)(10.3%)。
- 与未接种的流感患者相比,接种者最高体温略低,肌痛、寒战和头痛较少见。
- 分层分析中观察到的效应仅限于感染A(H3)或乙型病毒的患者。
- 调整年龄组、病毒(亚)型和季节后,仅头痛差异仍有统计学意义,接种者较少出现头痛(OR 0.69,95%CI 0.48-0.98)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Vaccine-induced protection against influenza is not optimal, however it has been suggested that the vaccine may reduce the severity of symptoms among those who develop illness despite being vaccinated. We tested this hypothesis within a countrywide, sentinel general practitioners-based surveillance system in France. We included 2277 individuals aged 65years or older (of whom 1293 had been vaccinated against influenza, 56.8%) who consulted a general practitioner because of an acute respiratory infection (ARI) during 2003-2014. All patients were taken a nasopharyngeal swab, and information was collected on demographic characteristics and symptoms at disease onset. All specimens were tested for respiratory viruses and, if positive for influenza, the virus type and subtype were determined. We compared the average maximum temperature and the frequency of each symptom, between non-vaccinated and vaccinated influenza patients. We then used logistic regression models to calculate the odds of presenting with each symptom between vaccinated vs. non-vaccinated patients, adjusting by age group, virus (sub)type and season. Overall, 675 ARI patients (29.6%) tested positive for influenza. The A(H3) virus caused the majority of cases (55.1%), followed by influenza B (22.9%), A not-subtyped (11.7%), and A(H1) (10.3%) viruses. Compared to non-vaccinated influenza patients, those who had been vaccinated had a slightly reduced maximum temperature and presented less frequently with myalgia, shivering and headache. In stratified analyses, the observed effect was limited to patients infected with A(H3) or type B viruses. After adjusting by age group, virus (sub)type and season, the difference remained statistically significant only for headache, which was less frequent among vaccinated individuals (odds ratio 0.69, 95% confidence intervals 0.48-0.98). In conclusion, the vaccine was found to be modestly associated with less severe clinical presentation of influenza among the elderly. Our findings reinforce the need for influenza vaccines providing better protection.
引用
- Mosnier A, Daviaud I, Caini S, et al. Does seasonal vaccination affect the clinical presentation of influenza among the elderly? A cross-sectional analysis in the outpatient setting in France, 2003-2014. Vaccine. 2017. PMID: 28291646. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2017.02.067
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。