基层医生对《平价医疗法案》时代经济问题与成人免疫接种的看法
2013年6月至10月对美国438名普通内科医生和401名家庭医生进行网络与邮寄调查,评估成人疫苗接种的经济障碍、对报销的满意度、对联邦医疗保险覆盖范围的了解及对《平价医疗法案》疫苗条款的知晓度。回应率分别为72%和59%,结果显示患者因费用拒绝疫苗、医生因经济原因不推荐疫苗,且对保险覆盖和法案条款了解不足。
要点
- 高达24%的普通内科医生和30%的家庭医生报告成人患者常因经济原因推迟或拒绝某些疫苗。
- 35%的医生因认为患者保险不覆盖而不推荐疫苗,38%因患者可在别处更便宜接种而不推荐。
- 对医疗补助和联邦医疗保险B部分支付疫苗购买和接种的满意度低,且36-71%的医生不了解联邦医疗保险对疫苗的覆盖情况。
核心结论
- 患者因经济原因拒绝疫苗,医生也因经济原因不推荐成人疫苗。
- 增加对私人和公共保险覆盖成人疫苗的了解,可能使医生更可能推荐疫苗,并在执业场所不提供特定疫苗时更好地转诊患者至其他接种提供者。
研究设计与样本
- 2013年6月至10月对美国全国网络的438名普通内科医生和401名家庭医生进行网络与邮寄调查。
主要发现
- 回应率:普通内科医生72%(317/438),家庭医生59%(236/401)。
- 在常规推荐疫苗的医生中,高达24%的普通内科医生和30%的家庭医生报告成人患者大多数时候因经济原因推迟或拒绝某些疫苗。
- 医生报告不推荐疫苗的原因包括认为患者保险不覆盖(35%)或患者可在别处更便宜接种(38%)。
- 在接诊相应保险患者的医生中,对医疗补助支付疫苗购买(16%非常不满意)和接种(14%非常不满意)的满意度最低,联邦医疗保险B部分支付疫苗购买(11%非常不满意)和接种(11%非常不满意)次之。
- 根据疫苗不同,36-71%的医生报告不了解联邦医疗保险如何覆盖该疫苗。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Financial barriers to adult vaccination are poorly understood. Our objectives were to assess among general internists (GIM) and family physicians (FP) shortly after Affordable Care Act (ACA) implementation: (1) proportion of adult patients deferring or refusing vaccines because of cost and frequency of physicians not recommending vaccines for financial reasons; (2) satisfaction with reimbursement for vaccine purchase and administration by payer type; (3) knowledge of Medicare coverage of vaccines; and (4) awareness of vaccine-specific provisions of the ACA. METHODS: We administered an Internet and mail survey from June to October 2013 to national networks of 438 GIMs and 401 FPs. RESULTS: Response rates were 72% (317/438) for GIM and 59% (236/401) for FP. Among physicians who routinely recommended vaccines, up to 24% of GIM and 30% of FP reported adult patients defer or refuse certain vaccines for financial reasons most of the time. Physicians reported not recommending vaccines because they thought the patient's insurance would not cover it (35%) or the patient could be vaccinated more affordably elsewhere (38%). Among physicians who saw patients with this insurance, dissatisfaction ('very dissatisfied') was highest for payments received from Medicaid (16% vaccine purchase, 14% vaccine administration) and Medicare Part B (11% vaccine purchase, 11% vaccine administration). Depending on the vaccine, 36-71% reported not knowing how Medicare covered the vaccine. Thirty-seven percent were 'not at all aware' and 19% were 'a little aware' of vaccine-specific provisions of the ACA. CONCLUSIONS: Patients are refusing and physicians are not recommending adult vaccinations for financial reasons. Increased knowledge of private and public insurance coverage for adult vaccinations might position physicians to be more likely to recommend vaccines and better enable them to refer patients to other vaccine providers when a particular vaccine or vaccines are not offered in the practice.
引用
- Hurley LP, Lindley MC, Allison MA, et al. Primary care physicians' perspective on financial issues and adult immunization in the Era of the Affordable Care Act. Vaccine. 2016. PMID: 28024954. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2016.12.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。