文献速递卫生政策与健康促进免疫规划

父母拒绝儿童疫苗与医疗忽视法

Parental Refusal of Childhood Vaccines and Medical Neglect Laws.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Public Health · 2016-11-17

研究通过Westlaw法律数据库检索1905至2016年法院判例,识别出9例以疫苗拒绝为唯一或主要原因的忽视诉讼案件。多数法院(9例中7例)认为疫苗拒绝构成忽视;在允许宗教豁免的4例中,法院裁定不构成忽视或仅在缺乏真诚宗教反对时构成忽视。部分州已有将父母疫苗拒绝视为医疗忽视的法律先例,但基于少量案件,各州应明确其法律立场。

要点

  • 9例案件中7例法院认为疫苗拒绝构成忽视。
  • 允许宗教豁免的4例中,法院裁定不构成忽视或仅在缺乏真诚宗教反对时构成忽视。
  • 部分州有法律先例,但基于少量案件,各州应明确立场。

核心结论

  • 部分州已有将父母疫苗拒绝视为医疗忽视的法律先例,但基于少量案件。
  • 各州应明确在其法律下疫苗拒绝是否构成医疗忽视。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用Westlaw法律数据库检索1905至2016年的法院判例。
  • 识别疫苗拒绝为忽视诉讼唯一或主要原因的案件。
  • 共纳入来自5个州的9例案件。
  • 同时查明裁决时是否提供宗教或哲学豁免。

主要发现

  • 9例案件中7例法院认为疫苗拒绝构成忽视。
  • 在允许宗教豁免的4例中,法院裁定不构成忽视或仅在缺乏真诚宗教反对时构成忽视。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文指出基于少量案件。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To examine the relation of vaccine refusal and medical neglect under child welfare laws. METHODS: We used the Westlaw legal database to search court opinions from 1905 to 2016 and identified cases in which vaccine refusal was the sole or a primary reason in a neglect proceeding. We also delineated if religious or philosophical exemptions from required school immunizations were available at the time of adjudication. RESULTS: Our search yielded 9 cases from 5 states. Most courts (7 of 9) considered vaccine refusal to constitute neglect. In the 4 cases decided in jurisdictions that permitted religious exemptions, courts either found that vaccine refusal did not constitute neglect or considered it neglect only in the absence of a sincere religious objection to vaccination. CONCLUSIONS: Some states have a legal precedent for considering parental vaccine refusal as medical neglect, but this is based on a small number of cases. Each state should clarify whether, under its laws, vaccine refusal constitutes medical neglect.

来源:Am J Public Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Parasidis E, Opel DJ. Parental Refusal of Childhood Vaccines and Medical Neglect Laws. Am J Public Health. 2016. PMID: 27854538

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。