结果相关无应答偏倚而非系统性误报导致COVID-19调查中疫苗接种率被高估
该研究结合丹麦大规模调查(n=393375)与个体行政登记数据,比较调查应答与实际接种行为。未发现系统性过度报告证据;
要点
- 调查应答者接种首剂和加强剂比例分别比受邀全样本高5.99和12.91个百分点。
- 未发现系统性过度报告,结果相关无应答偏倚是调查误差主要来源。
- 即使对社会人口学特征加权,调查估计仍可能高估疫情期接种率。
核心结论
- 结果相关无应答偏倚而非系统性误报是调查估计疫苗接种率误差的主要来源。
- 即使加权,调查估计仍可能高估疫情期疫苗接种率。
研究设计与样本
- 结合丹麦大规模调查(n=393375;女性50.42%;平均年龄49.46)与个体行政登记数据。
主要发现
- 调查应答与实际接种比较未发现系统性过度报告证据。
- 应答者比全部受邀者接种首剂可能性高5.99个百分点。
- 应答者比全部受邀者接种加强剂可能性高12.91个百分点。
临床怎么用
- 解读疫情期疫苗接种率调查估计时需考虑结果相关无应答偏倚,加权未必能完全纠正。
- 可链接行政登记数据验证调查估计并评估无应答偏倚方向与幅度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Authorities increasingly rely on surveys to generate real-time evidence on population behavior during epidemics, yet the reliability of such evidence is debated. We combine data from a large-scale Danish survey (n = 393,375; 50.42% women; mean age 49.46) conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic with individual-level administrative registries to identify sources of error in survey-based estimates of vaccine uptake. Comparing survey responses and actual vaccine uptake, we find no evidence of systematic overreporting. We evaluate nonresponse bias by comparing actual vaccination behavior among respondents with the full pool of 1.68 million invitees. Despite weighting for sociodemographic characteristics, respondents are 5.99 percentage points more likely to initiate vaccination and 12.91 percentage points more likely to receive a booster than the invited sample. These results indicate that outcome-related nonresponse bias-not misreporting-is the dominant source of survey error, implying that even weighted estimates may overstate vaccine uptake during epidemics.
引用
- Albertsen AE, Munch AH, Petersen MB, et al. Outcome-related nonresponse bias, not systematic misreporting, explains overestimation of vaccine uptake in COVID-19 surveys. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42967370. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.129315
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。