重新审视欧盟口蹄疫防控中的免疫后存活策略
2025年1月柏林附近水牛检出FMD,数周后斯洛伐克和匈牙利奶牛场确认不同FMDV毒株,2026年2月起塞浦路斯和莱斯沃斯暴发疫情。欧盟两受影响成员国采取相反策略:塞浦路斯全国免疫,希腊因担心贸易壁垒不免疫。WOAH陆生动物卫生法典强调反应性免疫且免疫后无需扑杀全部免疫动物即可恢复无疫状态,但欧盟新授权法规要求免疫区限制持续至最后一只免疫动物移除。
要点
- WOAH法典允许反应性免疫后不扑杀全部免疫动物即恢复无疫状态。
- 欧盟新授权法规要求免疫区限制维持至最后一只免疫动物移除。
- 现代FMD疫苗7天诱导稳健免疫,减少传播并支持DIVA策略。
核心结论
- 欧盟不应放弃高效且伦理更优的免疫后存活控制措施,以减轻未来口蹄疫暴发的社会经济后果。
- 欧洲面临FMDV传入的紧迫风险,需重新审视免疫后存活策略。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为针对欧盟口蹄疫防控策略的述评,基于2025年柏林附近水牛、斯洛伐克和匈牙利奶牛场及2026年塞浦路斯和莱斯沃斯暴发等事件。
主要发现
- 2025年1月柏林附近水牛检出FMD,数周后斯洛伐克和匈牙利奶牛场确认不同FMDV毒株。
- 2026年2月起塞浦路斯和莱斯沃斯面临FMD暴发。
- 塞浦路斯实施全国FMD免疫,希腊因担心贸易壁垒决定不免疫。
- 2001年FMD疫情席卷英国和欧洲大陆,数百万羊、牛和猪被扑杀。
关键数值与推荐
- WOAH陆生动物卫生法典强调反应性免疫,免疫后无需扑杀全部免疫动物即可恢复无疫状态。
- 欧盟2003年FMD指令含类似条款但已被废除,新授权法规要求免疫区所有限制维持至最后一只免疫动物移除。
- 现代FMD疫苗仅7天即可诱导稳健免疫,最大限度减少病毒传播并支持DIVA策略。
临床怎么用
- livestock密集的欧洲大陆中心地区若受影响,需权衡免疫后存活策略与贸易限制。
- 塞浦路斯因活畜、原料乳制品和鲜肉出口在经济中占比小,可承受贸易限制。
局限性
- 本文为述评,未提供原始研究数据或系统评价。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In January 2025, FMD was detected in water buffalos near Berlin. A few weeks later, a different FMDV-strain was confirmed on dairy farms in Slovakia and Hungary. Since February 2026, Cyprus and Lesvos are confronted with FMD-outbreaks. While Europe is rethinking its FMD-strategies, the two affected member states, Cyprus and Greece, take opposite approaches to control the disease. FMD-vaccination was pivotal for its eradication in many parts of the world. Such regions fought new outbreaks by traditional animal-disease-control. In 2001, a devastating FMD-epizootic swept across the UK and continental Europe. Several million sheep, cattle, and pigs were culled. In the aftermath, OIE (now: WOAH) and EU revised their FMD-strategies. Now, WOAH's Terrestrial Animal Health Code puts strong emphasis on reactive vaccination. An FMD-free status can be regained without slaughtering all vaccinated animals. By contrast, the European FMD Directive of 2003, which contained similar provisions, was repealed. Under the new Delegated Regulation, all restrictions on a vaccination zone are upheld until the last vaccinated animal is removed. Cyprus implemented country-wide FMD-vaccination despite these restrictions. Fearing trade barriers, Greece decided not to vaccinate. Were the consequences not so dramatic, a better head-to-head comparison would hardly be conceivable. Modern FMD-vaccines induce robust immunity after just seven days, minimize virus transmission and allow for DIVA strategies. In addition to the risks posed by global trade and travel, Europe faces major social, economic, and geopolitical challenges. The risk of FMDV incursions is imminent. Cyprus can afford to live with trade restrictions, because export of live animals, raw dairy products and fresh meat only play a minor role in its economy. This would be entirely different if livestock-dense regions in the heart of the continent were affected. The EU must not forgo highly effective and ethically superior control measures that could mitigate socio-economic consequences of future FMD-outbreaks.
引用
- Ganter M, Kerstin M, Böttcher J, et al. Reconsidering vaccinate-to-live strategies in EU foot-and-mouth disease control. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42837894. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.129217
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。