殖民主义如何驱动波多黎各健康的政治决定因素
本文以波多黎各为例,论证殖民主义作为更高阶决定因素影响健康的政治决定因素并进而影响下层决定因素,阻碍健康公平。作者用法律决定因素模型说明法律与判例如何制度化殖民主义并影响健康,并指出美国领土被系统性排除在联邦数据基础设施之外构成认知性抹除。结论认为实现健康公平与解放需 dismantling 殖民权力结构,否则有害政策与政治无能的「双重负担」无法解决。
要点
- 殖民主义作为更高阶健康决定因素,通过政治决定因素影响下层决定因素并阻碍健康公平。
- 法律与判例可制度化殖民主义,并通过法律决定因素模型影响人群健康。
- 美国领土被排除在联邦数据基础设施之外构成认知性抹除,导致数据不可见。
核心结论
- 殖民主义作为更高阶决定因素影响健康的政治决定因素,进而影响下层决定因素,阻碍健康公平。
- 实现健康公平与解放需 dismantling 殖民权力结构,否则有害政策与政治无能的「双重负担」无法解决。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为分析性文章,以波多黎各为焦点,运用法律决定因素模型展开论证。
- 文章扩展 Dawes 的政治决定因素框架,说明缺乏主权如何赋予外部利益权力、塑造健康并过滤本地声音。
主要发现
- 殖民主义通过多种机制运作,破坏将社区需求与健康公平政治行动相连接的倡导工具反馈回路。
- 法律与判例已将殖民主义制度化并影响健康。
- 数据不可见与美国领土被系统性排除在联邦数据基础设施之外构成一种认知性抹除。
临床怎么用
- 公共卫生分析与干预应将殖民主义作为更高阶决定因素纳入考量,而不仅限于民主语境下的政治决定因素框架。
- 应关注法律与判例如何制度化殖民主义并影响健康,以及数据不可见对健康公平的后果。
- 推动健康公平需解决缺乏主权与真正代表问题,并 dismantling 殖民权力结构。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Public health cannot be separated from politics. Although the relationship is often analyzed in democratic contexts, that framing limits the discussion to populations under colonial or neocolonial rule. Here I contend that colonialism functions as a higher-order determinant that influences the political determinants of health and, consequently, affects lower-level determinants, thereby hindering health equity. Colonialism operates through multiple mechanisms, disrupting the feedback loop in advocacy tools that connect community needs to political actions for health equity. Focusing on Puerto Rico, I use a legal determinants model to illustrate how laws and jurisprudence have institutionalized colonialism and affected health. This article expands Dawes's political determinants of health framework to demonstrate how a lack of sovereignty empowers external interests, shapes health, and filters local voices. Moreover, it shows that data invisibility and the systemic exclusion of US territories from federal data infrastructures constitute a form of epistemic erasure. The article concludes that achieving health equity and liberation requires dismantling colonial power structures, as the "double burden" of harmful policies and political impotence cannot be resolved without addressing lack of sovereignty and genuine representation. (Am J Public Health. 2026;116(11):1740-1749. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2026.308639).
引用
- Estremera-Rodriguez L. Invisible by Design: How Colonialism Drives Political Determinants of Health in Puerto Rico. Am J Public Health. 2026. PMID: 42659577. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2026.308639
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。