统计从来就是政治性的:公共卫生统计的政治维度
本文为观点文章,指出健康政策应遵循数据的说法本身具有政治含义,取决于收集哪些数据、采用何种分析方法以及证据标准如何应用或被忽略。作者认为权力与政治经济始终塑造数据,生物统计学家应直面统计的政治角色,而非回避。
要点
- 数据收集、分析方法与证据标准的选择均含政治含义,并非纯技术问题。
- 权力与政治经济始终塑造数据,即使数据被呈现为技术性和非政治性的。
- 生物统计学家应承认塑造工作的政治社会结构,并积极参与政治与统计的交汇。
核心结论
- 统计方法自诞生起就建立在对世界的假设之上,特定类型因果或成本效益证据的要求是政治主张而非技术主张。
- 生物统计学家不应通过回避公共卫生的政治层面来主张合法性,而应直面这一角色并充分参与政治与统计的交汇。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为发表于《美国公共卫生杂志》的观点文章,未报告系统检索或原始研究样本。
主要发现
- 健康政策应遵循数据的政治含义取决于收集哪些数据、使用何种分析方法以及应用或忽略哪些证据标准。
- 随着公共卫生的政治性走到公共政策前台,支撑公共卫生研究与实践的统计的政治性也随之凸显。
- 对某些政策要求特定类型的因果或成本效益证据,或界定何为证据,是政治而非技术的主张。
临床怎么用
- 生物统计学家应承认塑造其工作的政治与社会结构,并积极参与政治与统计交汇处的工作。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Politicians and advocates across the political spectrum have called for health policy to follow the data. But the political implications of this claim depend on the data that are collected, the analysis methods used, and the standards for evidence that are applied or ignored. As the political nature of public health has come to the forefront of public policy, so has the political aspect of the statistics that underpin public health research and practice. Power and political economy have always shaped data, even when data are portrayed as technocratic and apolitical. Statistical methods are built on assumptions about the world, as they have been since their inception. And the demand for a specific type of causal or cost‒benefit evidence for some policies, or what counts as evidence, is a political, not technical, claim. Rather than attempting to claim legitimacy by retreating from the political aspects of public health, biostatisticians need to confront this role head-on, acknowledge the political and social structures that shape our work, and engage fully at the intersection of the political and the statistical. (Am J Public Health. 2026;116(11):1727-1733. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2026.308640).
引用
- Kennedy-Shaffer L. The Statistical Is, and Always Has Been, Political. Am J Public Health. 2026. PMID: 42659582. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2026.308640
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。