破除流感误区与关注不良反应对医护人员接种意愿的实验研究
两项在线实验以医护人员为主、一般人群为对照,测试破除流感误区及应对不良反应担忧的材料是否提升接种意愿。实验1中破除误区显著提高两类人群接种意愿(均p<.001,均ηp2>0.12),追加不良反应图片无额外增益。实验2中医护人员无总体效应,但图片形式交互显著(p=.011,ηp2=0.04),其中一种提升意愿(p=.029,dz=0.25),一种边缘反弹(p=.052,dz=-0.21)。
要点
- 破除流感误区材料可可靠提升医护人员和一般人群的接种意愿。
- 在误区材料外追加不良反应图片未额外提升医护人员接种意愿。
- 针对医护人员的不良反应信息形式效果不一,部分材料或致边缘反弹。
核心结论
- 破除流感误区材料可可靠提高接种意愿,而明确应对轻微不良反应未可靠提升意愿,部分材料甚至边缘降低意愿。
研究设计与样本
- 两项在线实验,实验1为医护人员n=514、一般人群n=401,随机分配含或不含不良反应图片的误区材料。
- 实验2为医护人员n=535、一般人群n=1200,随机分配四种不良反应信息图片格式,主要结局为接种意愿。
主要发现
- 实验1中破除误区显著提高两类样本接种意愿(均p<.001,均ηp2>0.12),追加不良反应图片无额外提升。
- 实验2中医护人员无总体效应,但图片格式交互显著(p=.011,ηp2=0.04)。
- 实验2中医护人员一种图片提升意愿(p=.029,dz=0.25),两种无效,一种边缘反弹(p=.052,dz=-0.21)。
- 实验2一般人群总体意愿提升(p<.001,dz=0.15),无交互效应。
临床怎么用
- 面向医护人员的接种宣传可优先采用破除流感误区材料以提升接种意愿。
- 针对医护人员的不良反应信息材料应在实施前预先测试,避免无效或反弹。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Seasonal influenza causes significant global harms, and vaccinating healthcare workers (HCW) is central to protecting both staff and patients. However, HCW influenza vaccination rates remain below targets. Misconceptions, particularly concerns about adverse reactions, are frequently cited barriers, and many campaigns use myth-busting materials to counter these beliefs. This study tested whether correcting influenza myths and addressing concerns about adverse reactions leads to an increase in vaccine intentions. METHODS: Two online experimental studies were conducted. HCW participants were of primary interest but a general population sample was included for comparison. In Experiment 1 (HCW n = 514; general population n = 401), participants viewed images debunking common influenza myths, with randomisation to materials that either included or excluded an additional image addressing adverse reactions. Experiment 2 (HCW n = 535; general population n = 1200) focused exclusively on adverse reaction messaging, with participants randomised to one of four image formats. Vaccination intention was the primary outcome. RESULTS: In Experiment 1, myth-busting significantly increased vaccination intentions (all p < .001, all ηp2 > 0.12) in both samples. Adding an adverse reactions image produced no additional increase. In Experiment 2, no overall effects emerged for HCW, but a significant interaction (p = .011, ηp2 = 0.04) indicated that effects varied by image: one increased intentions (p = .029, dz = 0.25), two showed null effects, and one produced a marginal backfire effect (p = .052 dz = -0.21). In the general population sample, intentions increased overall (p < .001, dz = 0.15) with no interaction. CONCLUSIONS: Vaccination intentions were reliably higher after viewing myth-busting materials than before, but control intentions were not. Myth-busting is therefore an effective approach to increasing influenza vaccination intentions. In contrast, explicitly addressing mild adverse reactions did not reliably raise intentions and, for one set of materials, marginally reduced them. Campaigns targeting HCW should therefore test adverse reaction messaging before implementation.
引用
- Bott L, Liu J, Challenger A, et al. Myth-busting influenza and fear of adverse reactions in healthcare workers: two experimental studies on vaccination intentions. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42664528. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.129086
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。