默认预约转换:COVID-19疫苗接种预预约的形成性评估
荷兰2023年秋将部分人群COVID-19疫苗接种从自选预约改为预预约。混合方法研究显示预预约被部分人视为冒昧或不方便,但也视为有用辅助;实验发现自选预约感知负担更低但不改变接种意向。保守推荐对前一年接种过COVID-19疫苗的老年人实施预预约。
要点
- 预预约与自选预约在COVID-19疫苗接种意向上无差异。
- 自选预约感知负担更低但未转化为接种意向差异。
- 预预约同时引发负面和正面情绪,对犹豫人群效果相似。
核心结论
- 预预约不改变COVID-19疫苗接种意向,且自选预约被感知更轻松愉快,保守推荐对前一年接种过COVID-19疫苗的老年人实施预预约。
研究设计与样本
- 两阶段形成性评估:阶段1为15次访谈,阶段2为代表性在线面板(n=1.886)实验,评估预预约与自选预约的感知负担及对接种意向的影响。
主要发现
- 访谈显示预预约被部分人视为冒昧或不方便,但也视为有用辅助,有时同一人持两种看法。
- 实验参与者认为自选预约感知负担更低(Coefficient=-0.23),但未转化为接种意向差异(Adjusted OR=1.11)。
- 犹豫亚组结果相似(Coefficient=-0.25;Adjusted OR=0.88)。
关键数值与推荐
- 预预约vs自选预约感知负担:Coefficient=-0.23;接种意向:Adjusted OR=1.11。
- 犹豫亚组:感知负担Coefficient=-0.25;接种意向Adjusted OR=0.88。
临床怎么用
- 对前一年接种过COVID-19疫苗的老年人可保守推荐预预约,但需注意其可能引发负面情绪且不改变接种意向。
局限性
- 研究仅评估接种意向而非实际接种行为,且为形成性评估,结论需谨慎推广。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In autumn 2023, COVID-19 vaccination invitations in the Netherlands shifted from self-scheduling to pre-booked appointments for selected groups. While defaulting to pre-booked slots may increase uptake, potential rebound effects remain unclear. We examine preferences between appointment types, their effect on vaccination intentions, and whether effects are different for individuals hesitant about this vaccination round. METHODS: A mixed-methods approach was used to assess vaccination intentions for three groups (<60 with influenza vaccination indication, 60-69 and 70+ years) eligible for pre-booked appointments. In a two-phase formative evaluation study, we examined attitudes around pre-booked appointments in 15 interviews (phase 1) and experimentally tested (phase 2) perceived burden of pre-booked appointments vs self-scheduled appointments and their effect on vaccination intentions in a representative online panel (n = 1.886) and those who experience hesitancy about this vaccination. FINDINGS: Interviews (phase 1) showed that pre-booked appointments are seen as presumptuous or inconvenient by some, but also as a useful aid in support of vaccination uptake, sometimes by the same people. Participants in the experiment (phase 2) indicated to perceive self-scheduling as less burdensome (Coefficient = -0.23) but this perception did not translate to differences in vaccination intentions (Adjusted OR = 1.11) Similar results were observed in the hesitant subgroup (Coefficient = -0.25; Adjusted OR = 0.88). DISCUSSION: In our study pre-booked appointments do not change COVID-19 vaccination intentions. As pre-booked appointments evoked negative and positive sentiments and self-scheduling was found easier and more pleasant, we conservatively recommend its implementation for older adults who received their COVID-19 vaccination the previous year.
引用
- Sanders JG, Kroese F, Mehra S, et al. Switching the default: a formative evaluation of pre-booked appointments on COVID-19 vaccination uptake and effects on intended uptake. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42546637. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.128967
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。