文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

对COVID-19疫苗和医疗种族主义中种族内群体担忧的高估

Overestimation of racial ingroup worry about the COVID-19 vaccine and medical racism.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2026-08-17

研究调查了围绕COVID-19疫苗接种和医疗种族主义是否存在多元无知现象,聚焦黑人和白人两个种族群体的反疫苗运动。通过Qualtrics面板样本(N=2425,黑人1209,白人1216)询问担忧程度及对平均美国人担忧的感知。结果显示黑人在所有项目上担忧高于白人,黑人持续高估其他黑人的担忧,白人仅高估对COVID-19项目的担忧,自身担忧和开放思维预测高估。

要点

  • 黑人参与者对COVID-19疫苗和医疗种族主义的担忧均高于白人参与者。
  • 黑人参与者持续高估其他黑人对所有相关问题的担忧程度。
  • 白人参与者仅高估其他白人对COVID-19相关问题的担忧,未高估医疗种族主义担忧。

核心结论

  • 存在多元无知现象:黑人高估同组担忧,白人仅对COVID-19项目高估同组担忧。
  • 自身担忧和开放思维是两组高估他人担忧的预测因素。

研究设计与样本

  • 通过Qualtrics面板招募50%黑人和50%白人美国人的横断面样本,共N=2425(黑人n=1209,白人n=1216)。
  • 询问参与者对医疗种族主义、HIV misinformation、COVID-19疫苗安全性和疫苗侵犯个人权利的担忧,并估计平均白人和黑人美国人的担忧。

主要发现

  • 黑人在所有项目上的担忧水平高于白人。
  • 黑人参与者一致高估其他黑人对所有COVID-19相关和医疗种族主义相关问题的担忧。
  • 白人参与者仅高估其他白人对COVID-19相关项目的担忧,未高估医疗种族主义相关项目。
  • 自身担忧和 exhibiting Actively Open-Minded Thinking 是两组高估他人担忧的预测因素。

临床怎么用

  • 针对黑人社区的疫苗沟通需纠正对群体担忧的高估,减少多元无知。
  • 针对白人社区的疫苗沟通可侧重COVID-19相关担忧的规范化反馈。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

We investigate whether there is pluralistic ignorance-a group-level shared misperception of what other group members are doing, thinking, or feeling-around COVID-19 vaccination and medical racism. We focus on two distinct anti-vaccination movements grounded in distinct racial groups: Black Americans and White Americans. Black American vaccine hesitancy is uniquely grounded in the history and continued reality of medical racism. White American vaccine hesitancy is influenced by factors including social media use, institutional mistrust, and psychological reactance. A Qualtrics panel sample (N = 2425) obtained by recruiting 50% Black (n = 1209) and 50% White (n = 1216) Americans were asked how worried they were regarding medical racism, HIV misinformation, COVID-19 vaccine safety, and whether the COVID-19 vaccine was violating individual rights. They were then asked how worried they felt the average White American and average Black American were on these issues. Black Americans had higher levels of worry on all items than White Americans. Among Black participants, there was a consistent pattern of overestimation of other Black Americans' worry across all issues-both COVID-19 related and medical racism related. Among the White participants, overestimation of group worry was only present for the COVID-19 items, not the items relating to medical racism. For both groups, one's own worry about each outcome and exhibiting Actively Open-Minded Thinking were predictors of overestimations of other's worry.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Heiman SL, Geiger N. Overestimation of racial ingroup worry about the COVID-19 vaccine and medical racism. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42607628. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.129046

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。