瑞士1877-2022年白喉长期流行病学与20世纪中期疫苗接种规划的影响
该研究汇编并数字化了瑞士1877至2022年白喉发病、住院和死亡的多项历史时间序列,采用贝叶斯负二项模型估计无疫苗接种情景下的反事实发病与死亡轨迹。结果显示,1877至2022年共记录35,271例白喉死亡,其中99.5%发生在20世纪40年代广泛接种疫苗之前;日内瓦自1933年实施强制接种后,观察到的发病与死亡持续低于预测反事实水平;1943年全国推荐接种后所有州白喉均快速下降,但强制接种州的下降更早更显著,残余暴发也更少更小。
要点
- 1877-2022年瑞士共记录35,271例白喉死亡,99.5%发生于20世纪40年代广泛接种前。
- 日内瓦1933年强制接种后,发病与死亡持续低于无接种的反事实预测。
- 1943年全国推荐接种后各州白喉均快速下降,强制接种州下降更早更显著。
核心结论
- 疫苗接种前发病与死亡的下降减轻了白喉负担,但持续控制只有通过疫苗接种才能实现。
研究设计与样本
- 研究汇编并数字化瑞士1877至2022年白喉发病、住院和死亡的多项历史时间序列,包括1910年起的州级发病数据,采用贝叶斯负二项模型估计无反事实发病与死亡轨迹。
主要发现
- 1877至2022年共记录35,271例白喉死亡,其中99.5%发生在20世纪40年代广泛接种疫苗之前。
- 发病与死亡呈阶段性下降,但在第一次世界大战前后、1930年和第二次世界大战前后出现重大流行波。
- 日内瓦实施强制接种后,观察到的发病与死亡持续低于预测反事实水平。
- 1943年全国推荐接种后所有州白喉快速下降,但强制接种州下降更早更显著,残余暴发更少更小。
临床怎么用
- 在制定白喉免疫策略时,应关注强制接种相较推荐/自愿接种对加速发病下降和减少残余暴发的潜在作用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Diphtheria was a major cause of childhood morbidity and mortality in Switzerland until the mid-20th century. While mortality declined already before vaccination due to improvements in living conditions and medical care, recurrent epidemic waves persisted. The role of vaccination programmes introduced in the 1930s and 1940s has not been systematically quantified for Switzerland. DATA AND METHODS: We compiled and digitised multiple historical time series on diphtheria morbidity, hospitalisations and mortality in Switzerland from 1877 to 2022, including cantonal incidence data from 1910 onwards. Using Bayesian negative binomial models, we estimated counterfactual incidence and mortality trajectories in the absence of vaccination. We compared observed trends with model predictions, focusing on the early mandatory programme in Geneva (from 1933) and on differences between cantons with mandatory versus recommended/facultative vaccination following the nationwide recommendation in 1943. RESULTS: Between 1877 and 2022, 35,271 diphtheria deaths were recorded, with 99.5% occurring before widespread vaccination in the 1940s. Incidence and mortality declined in several stages but were punctuated by major epidemic waves around World War I, 1930, and World War II. After the introduction of mandatory vaccination in Geneva, observed incidence and mortality were consistently lower than predicted counterfactual levels. Following the nationwide vaccination recommendation, diphtheria declined rapidly in all cantons, but reductions were earlier and more pronounced in cantons with mandatory vaccination, which also experienced fewer and smaller residual outbreaks. DISCUSSION: Our findings show that while pre-vaccination declines reduced diphtheria burden, sustained containment was only achieved through vaccination.
引用
- Tuor SM, Matthes KL, Lang P, et al. Diphtheria in Switzerland, 1877-2022: long-term epidemiology and the impact of mid-20th-century vaccination programs. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42623711. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.129064
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。