ACA时代美国成人疫苗意愿与接种提升策略:系统综述与元回归
该系统综述纳入92项研究(元回归79项),评估2010-2025年美国成人疫苗意愿与接种干预策略。元回归显示优先特定人群、服务质量和社区招募与更高接种率相关,现场接种在新冠应急外未显示普遍效应;GRADE证据确定性为低至中等。
要点
- 优先特定人群、服务质量改进和社区组织招募与更高接种率显著相关。
- 现场接种与更低接种率相关,但仅限新冠应急响应情境,非普遍效应。
- 信息框架与教育宣传最常用,多组分设计和社区合作效果最佳。
核心结论
- 有效成人疫苗接种策略是多因素的,减少摩擦比单纯说服更有效。
- 服务质量改进、优先人群聚焦和社区招募是更高接种率的最强预测因素。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA 2020的系统综述与元回归,检索PubMed、Web of Science、Ovid/MEDLINE和EBSCOhost至2025年12月。
- 从11219条记录中纳入92项研究,其中79项进行元回归,研究设计以RCT为主。
- 使用EPHPP工具评估质量,GRADE评估证据确定性,按WHO BeSD模型分类策略。
主要发现
- 元回归(调整R2=0.229)中,优先特定人群(b=0.121,p=.027)、服务质量改进策略(b=0.226,p=.040)、通过社区伙伴组织招募(b=0.585,p=.005)或医疗机构招募(b=0.230,p=.040)与显著更高接种率相关。
- 现场接种与更低接种率相关(b=-0.185,p=.033),敏感性分析确认该效应特定于COVID-19大流行应急响应情境,而非策略的普遍效应。
- 叙事合成显示信息框架和教育宣传是最常部署的策略,多组分设计和社区伙伴关系显示最有利结果。
- GRADE证据确定性为低至中等。
临床怎么用
- 优先采用服务质量改进、聚焦特定优先人群和通过社区伙伴或医疗机构招募的干预策略。
- 避免将现场接种作为通用策略,其负相关可能仅反映新冠应急响应情境。
局限性
- GRADE证据确定性为低至中等,需更高质量、关注公平的研究。
- 纳入研究以RCT为主,流感与COVID-19疫苗研究最常见,其他疫苗证据可能有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccine-preventable diseases continue to burden U.S. population health. Despite the Affordable Care Act (ACA) eliminating cost-sharing for recommended vaccines in 2010, adult vaccination rates persistently fall below Healthy People 2030 targets, signaling that access alone is insufficient. OBJECTIVES: To synthesize peer-reviewed literature (2010-2025) on interventions designed to increase vaccine intention or uptake among U.S. adults; characterize strategies, populations, settings, and study quality; and identify predictors of vaccine uptake rate. METHODS: Following PRISMA 2020 guidelines, a multi-database search was conducted across PubMed, Web of Science, Ovid/MEDLINE, and EBSCOhost, with a final updated search in December 2025. Dual independent reviewers screened studies in two stages. Quality was assessed using the EPHPP tool and certainty evaluated using GRADE. Strategies were categorized per the WHO Behavioral and Social Drivers of Vaccination (BeSD) Model. A meta-regression was conducted on 79 studies, with narrative synthesis across all 92 included studies. RESULTS: Of 11,219 records, 92 studies were included. Study designs were predominantly RCTs; Influenza and COVID-19 vaccines were most commonly studied. In the meta-regression (adjusted R2 = 0.229), prioritizing a specific population (b=0.121, p=.027), using service quality improvement strategies (b=0.226, p=.040), and recruiting through community-based partner organizations (b=0.585, p=.005) or healthcare organizations (b=0.230, p=.040) were associated with significantly higher vaccine uptake rates. Onsite vaccination was associated with lower uptake rates (b=-0.185, p=.033), an effect confirmed as specific to the COVID-19 pandemic emergency-response context rather than a generalizable effect of the strategy in sensitivity analysis. Narrative synthesis identified message framing and educational campaigns as the most frequently deployed strategies, with multi-component designs and community partnerships showing the most favorable outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Effective adult vaccination strategies were multifactorial. Service quality improvement, priority population focus, and community-based recruitment were the strongest predictors of higher uptake. Findings support the WHO BeSD model's Practical Issues domain: reducing friction outperformed persuasion alone. GRADE certainty remained LOW to MODERATE, emphasizing the need for higher-quality, equity-focused research. REGISTRATION: This systematic review was registered at Open Science Framework: 10.17605/OSF.IO/SM7YD.
引用
- Hensley AA, Jiles KA, Edwards S, et al. Characteristics of successful and unsuccessful strategies to increase vaccine intention and improve vaccine uptake for U.S. adult populations in the Affordable Care Act era (2010-2025): a systematic review and meta-regression. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42430872. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.128910
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。