中低收入国家零剂次儿童与常规免疫覆盖的地理空间制图:范围综述
该范围综述纳入102篇来自68个中低收入国家的文献,系统梳理用于预测或制图零剂次(ZD)流行率和常规免疫(RI)覆盖的地理空间方法。研究发现多数研究制图RI覆盖指标,仅19.6%评估ZD流行率且定义不一致;方法以聚类和空间自相关分析(54%)及空间插值(45%)为主,数据过度依赖调查、边缘人群代表性不足。
要点
- 中低收入国家地理空间制图研究快速增长,但87%集中于埃塞俄比亚、尼日利亚和印度。
- 仅19.6%研究评估零剂次流行率,且零剂次定义存在两种不一致标准。
- 方法以探索性空间分析为主,小区域估计(13%)和机器学习(8%)应用有限。
核心结论
- 中低收入国家常规免疫覆盖的地理空间制图正在扩展,但主要依赖探索性方法,不足以实现精准定位。
- 专门的零剂次制图仍然稀少,且受限于调查数据依赖、常规数据利用不足和边缘人群代表性不足。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索六个数据库截至2025年发表的同行评议文章,纳入102篇来自68个中低收入国家的文献。
- 提取研究特征、协变量类型与来源、建模方法及局限性,并按制图常规免疫覆盖与估计零剂次流行率分层总结。
主要发现
- 70%的文献发表于2021至2024年,87%的研究集中在埃塞俄比亚、尼日利亚和印度。
- 多数研究制图常规免疫覆盖指标,仅19.6%评估零剂次流行率,且基于两种不同定义。
- 协变量数据以人口学因素为主(49%),冲突地区和游牧人群等难以触及情境的代表性有限。
- 方法包括聚类和自相关分析(54%)、空间插值(45%)、小区域估计(13%)和机器学习(8%)。
- 关键缺口包括零剂次定义不一致、数据不准确和稀缺、常规疫苗接种数据利用有限。
临床怎么用
- 利用地理空间制图识别免疫空白区域和边缘人群,但需注意现有方法多为探索性,精准定位能力有限。
- 应整合调查数据与常规免疫数据,改进零剂次定义一致性,并加强地方分析能力建设。
局限性
- 零剂次定义不一致影响研究间可比性。
- 数据不准确和稀缺,常规疫苗接种数据利用有限。
- 冲突地区和游牧人群等边缘群体代表性不足。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Zero-dose (ZD) children remain a critical public health concern, particularly in low- and lower-middle-income countries (LLMICs), where over 80% of the global ZD population resides, disproportionately concentrated among the most marginalised. Geospatial approaches have emerged as effective tools for identifying and targeting immunisation gaps. However, no review has systematically documented the spatial approaches used to predict or map ZD prevalence and routine immunisation (RI) coverage. This scoping review addresses this gap across LLMICs. METHODS: We searched six databases for peer-reviewed articles published up to 2025, on spatial modelling of childhood vaccination coverage in LLMICs. We extracted details on study characteristics, covariate types and sources, modelling methods, and limitations; stratifying findings between studies mapping RI coverage and those estimating ZD prevalence. Articles were thematically summarised focusing on geospatial data, modelling approaches, and corresponding gaps. RESULTS: We included 102 articles from 68 LLMICs, with 70% published between 2021 and 2024, and 87% concentrated in Ethiopia, Nigeria, and India. Most studies mapped RI coverage indicators, only 19.6% assessed ZD prevalence, based on two distinct definitions. Studies relied predominantly on survey-based vaccination data. Covariate data were dominated by demographic factors (49%) with limited representation of hard-to-reach contexts such as conflict areas and nomadic populations. Methods included clustering and autocorrelation analysis (54%), spatial interpolation (45%), small-area estimation (13%), and machine learning (8%). Key gaps included inconsistent ZD definitions, data inaccuracies and scarcity, and limited use of routine vaccination data. CONCLUSIONS: Geospatial mapping of RI coverage is expanding across LLMICs but relies predominantly on exploratory approaches insufficient for precise targeting, while dedicated ZD mapping remains sparse. Geospatial modelling is constrained by overreliance on survey data, limited application of routine data, and underrepresentation of marginalised populations. Addressing these gaps requires integrated data systems, and reproducible modelling approaches underpinned by sustained investment in local analytical capacity.
引用
- Njogu AM, Musau MM, Srivastava S, et al. Geospatial approaches for mapping zero-dose prevalence and routine childhood immunisation coverage in low- and lower-middle-income countries: A scoping review. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42442083. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.128904
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。