中低收入国家青少年与成年移民的补种及全生命周期疫苗接种政策分析
该政策分析系统检索2000年1月至2025年2月间136个中低收入国家的国家及次国家级政策文件,评估针对青少年(10-19岁)和成年(>19岁)移民的补种与全生命周期疫苗接种政策。结果显示,仅9个(6.6%)国家制定了移民包容性常规疫苗补种或全生命周期接种政策,而COVID-19政策中移民包容性较广,57个(41.9%)国家有相关部署。
要点
- 136个中低收入国家中仅9个(6.6%)有移民包容性常规疫苗补种或全生命周期接种政策。
- 指南中最常纳入的疫苗为HPV(6国,4.4%)和MR/MMR(5国,3.7%)。
- COVID-19疫苗政策中移民包容性较广,57个(41.9%)国家有相关部署。
核心结论
- 大多数中低收入国家缺乏确保青少年和成年移民获得补种及全生命周期疫苗接种的政策。
- 尽管有充分证据表明这些人群免疫不足,移民包容性常规疫苗补种政策仍很罕见。
研究设计与样本
- 采用框架分析法,对136个中低收入国家的国家及次国家级政策、操作指南、法律和框架进行比较政策分析。
- 系统检索数据库和灰色文献,包括卫生部网站和主要国际组织(2000年1月至2025年2月),并联系卫生部和国家专家获取未发表政策。
- 纳入标准聚焦于青少年(10-19岁)和/或成年(>19岁)移民(包括难民、无证移民、寻求庇护者、国内流离失所者和移民工人)的补种和全生命周期疫苗接种政策。
主要发现
- 33个政策与指南来源符合纳入标准(15篇同行评议,18篇灰色文献),报告了57个中低收入国家的移民疫苗接种政策。
- 移民包容性常规疫苗补种或全生命周期接种政策仅在9个(6.6%)中低收入国家中发现。
- 在上述9国中,3国(33.3%)仅关注疫情响应或临时性规定,4国(44.4%)采用一般国家免疫规划并对移民机会性补种但无移民特异性操作指南,2国(22.2%)通过正式政策框架或结构化伙伴关系承认移民权利。
- 政策同时针对青少年和成年人的国家有9个(6.6%),针对难民的有9个(6.6%),其他移民群体较少被明确指定。
- 中低收入国家青少年和成年移民指南中最常出现的疫苗为HPV(6国,占136国的4.4%)和MR/MMR(5国,3.7%),其次为OCV和HepB(各3国,2.2%),脊灰、破伤风和伤寒仅在极少数国家纳入。
关键数值与推荐
- 移民包容性常规疫苗补种或全生命周期接种政策覆盖率为9/136(6.6%)。
- 在9个有相关政策的国家中,仅疫情响应或临时性规定占3/9(33.3%),一般国家免疫规划机会性补种占4/9(44.4%),正式政策框架承认权利占2/9(22.2%)。
- 疫苗接种史不确定时明确推荐推定补种的国家占3/9(33.3%)。
- 指南中纳入HPV疫苗的国家为6/136(4.4%),MR/MMR为5/136(3.7%),OCV和HepB各为3/136(2.2%)。
- COVID-19移民包容性政策或推广覆盖57/136(41.9%)中低收入国家。
临床怎么用
- 各国政府应明确移民的疫苗接种权利,采用移民包容性指南。
- 加强交付和监测系统,以覆盖在原籍国或过境期间错过疫苗、剂次或加强针且面临就医障碍的人群。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Adolescent and adult migrants in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are often under-immunised because of disrupted vaccination in childhood and barriers to care, increasing the risk of vaccine-preventable diseases. WHO's Immunization Agenda 2030 strengthens calls for life-course immunisation and inclusion of marginalised groups in catch-up initiatives (including Td/Tdap, IPV, MR/MMR, HepB, HPV). Despite evidence from Europe that migrants are frequently missed, it is unclear how far LMIC policies include adolescents and adults beyond child-focused programmes. We analysed catch-up and life-course vaccination policies, operational guidance, laws and frameworks across 136 LMICs. METHODS: Using framework analysis, we conducted a comparative policy analysis of national and subnational policies, operational guidance, laws and frameworks on catch-up and life-course vaccination for adolescents (10-19 years) and/or adults (>19 years) migrants (including refugees, undocumented migrants, asylum seekers, Internally Displaced Person (IDPs) and migrants workers) across LMICs. We did systematic database and grey-literature searches including and Ministry of Health websites, key international organisations (Jan 2000-Feb 2025), and contacted health ministries and national experts to locate unpublished policies and guidelines. RESULTS: 33 policy and guidance sources met the inclusion criteria (15 peer-reviewed; 18 grey literature), reporting vaccination policies for migrants across 57 LMICs. Evidence clustered into two policy domains, routine vaccinations and COVID-19. We found that migrant-inclusive catch-up or life-course vaccination policies for routine vaccines were rare, identified in only 9 (6.6%) of 136 LMICs. 3 (33.3%) of these countries focused on outbreak-responsive or ad hoc provisions only, 4 (44.4%) applied general national immunisation schedules with opportunistic catch-up to migrants (but without migrant-specific operational guidance), and 2 (22.2%) recognised migrant entitlement through formal policy frameworks or structured partnerships. Policies targeted both adolescents and adults in 9 (6.6%) of 136 LMICs, and refugees in 9 (6.6%) LMICs, while other migrant groups were less consistently specified. Vaccines most commonly appearing in guidelines for adolescent and adult migrants in LMICs were HPV in 6 (4.4% of 136 LMICs) and MR/MMR in 5 (3.7%), followed by OCV and HepB in 3 (2.2%) countries each. Polio, tetanus and typhoid were also included in rare cases. Where vaccination history was uncertain, only 3 (33.3%) countries explicitly recommended presumptive catch-up vaccination. For COVID-19, vaccination policies demostrated broad migrant inclusion: 57 (41.9%) of 136 LMICs documented migrant-inclusive policies or rollout targeting adolescents and/or adult migrants through national deployment plans or emergency strategies. CONCLUSION: Most LMICs lack policies ensuring adolescent and adult migrants access catch-up and life-course vaccination, despite ample evidence that these are under-immunised populations. Governments should clarify entitlements, adopt migrant-inclusive guidance, and strengthen delivery and monitoring systems to reach people who miss vaccines, doses, and boosters in origin countries or during transit, and who face barriers to care.
引用
- Faijue DD, Bouaddi O, Segui AO, et al. Catch-up and life-course vaccination policies for adult and adolescent migrants in low-and-middle income countries: A policy analysis. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 42172819. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.128645
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。