疫苗政策科学:2025年12月ACIP会议的透明度缺失、错误信息与决策过程缺陷
乙肝疫苗讨论未采用证据到推荐框架,最终取消出生剂量的推荐缺乏证据支持,可能增加乙肝感染率。
要点
- ACIP成员发言含超过60处实质性错误信息。
- 乙肝疫苗推荐取消出生剂量缺乏证据支持,可能有害。
核心结论
- ACIP审议质量持续下降,其政策推荐可能对公共卫生有害。
主要发现
- 会前公众评论多来自支持乙肝疫苗普遍出生剂量的专家和卫生组织。
- 会议仅讨论2个议题,而通常为9个以上。
- ACIP成员发言含超过60处实质性错误信息。
- 乙肝疫苗讨论未使用证据到推荐框架,最终推荐取消出生剂量缺乏证据支持。
关键数值与推荐
- ACIP成员发言含超过60处实质性错误信息。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccine policy has great urgency as infectious disease are resurgent. To understand the health of US vaccine policymaking, this report provides a comprehensive analysis of the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices' (ACIP) December 2025 meeting. METHODS: We conducted a thematic analysis of pre-meeting public comments. We characterize the meeting's topics. We systematically compared the transparency of ACIP meetings before and after its members were replaced in June 2025. We characterized the accuracy of meeting comments based on analyses by the Evidence Collective. For the hepatitis B vaccine votes, we summarized evidence presented and analyzed committee processes and recommendations. RESULTS: Most pre-meeting public comments were from experts and health organizations supporting the universal birth dose of hepatitis B vaccine and explaining its safety and benefits. The meeting addressed few topics (2 vs. the usual 9+ topics). The meeting had low transparency, with an overall score of 53% (well below the 97% score for the October 2024 meeting). Presentations and comments by ACIP members contained over 60 instances of substantial misinformation. The hepatitis B vaccine discussions failed to use an Evidence to Recommendations Framework analysis and reflected inadequate preparation, disorganization, and misinterpretations of epidemiological data to suit a seemingly predetermined policy position. The resulting recommendation to remove the birth dose lacked supporting evidence and is likely to increase rates of hepatitis B infection and associated disease. CONCLUSIONS: The quality of ACIP deliberations continues to degrade, and its policy recommendations are likely harmful to public health.
引用
- Loehr J, Moser CA, Asturias EJ, et al. Science for vaccine policy: Lack of transparency, misinformation, and poor decision processes at the December 2025 ACIP meeting. Vaccine. 2026. PMID: 41719792. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2026.128338
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。