赞比亚社区成员与医护人员对未来成人疫苗接种决策驱动因素的优劣尺度研究
本研究在赞比亚卢萨卡对472名社区成员和医护人员开展优劣尺度(BWS)调查,评估22项疫苗接种因素对决策的相对重要性。结果显示疾病特征和疫苗特征最重要,潜在类别分析识别出社区成员5组、医护人员2组偏好亚型,提示需差异化沟通与交付策略。
要点
- 疾病特征与疫苗效力、保护时长是成人疫苗接种决策的最重要因素。
- 社区成员存在5种偏好亚型,医护人员存在2种,需分组定制策略。
- 所有亚型均优先考虑疫苗针对的具体疾病,但其他动机差异明显。
核心结论
- 疾病特异性因素普遍影响疫苗偏好,但社区成员和医护人员内部存在异质性,需差异化交付与沟通策略并利用信任信源。
研究设计与样本
- 在赞比亚卢萨卡开展的优劣尺度(BWS)调查,纳入22项疫苗接种因素,共472名参与者(社区成员381人,医护人员91人)。
- 采用分层贝叶斯计算平均偏好权重(MPWs),并用潜在类别多项logit分析(LCA)识别偏好组。
主要发现
- 参与者中位年龄30.0岁,53.8%为女性,9.6%为HIV阳性。
- 疾病特征(具体疾病、感染可能性、严重程度)和疫苗特征(效力、保护时长)是影响决策的最重要因素。
- LCA识别出社区成员5组:个人健康导向(31.0%)、疾病防护与社会意识(22.8%)、激励驱动(18.9%)、疫苗谨慎(15.5%)、强制驱动(11.8%)。
- 医护人员2组:疾病与效力驱动(62.6%)、务实导向(37.4%)。
临床怎么用
- 针对不同偏好亚型设计沟通信息,如对激励驱动组强调财务激励,对疫苗谨慎组关注疫苗来源与安全性。
- 利用信任信源传递疾病严重性和疫苗效力信息,以提升未来成人疫苗接种率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Several new vaccines for adults may soon become available, but low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) have limited experience with adult vaccination programs beyond COVID-19. Understanding the factors that influence vaccination decisions among community members and healthcare workers (HCWs) in such settings will be critical for optimizing uptake and rollout strategies. METHODS: We conducted a Best-Worst Scaling (BWS) exercise to determine which vaccination factors (n = 22) most influenced adult community members and HCWs in Lusaka, Zambia, for newly introduced vaccines. Vaccination factors included disease characteristics, vaccine characteristics, vaccine-related concerns, vaccine delivery features, social norms, and external motivators. Mean preference weights (MPWs), indicating relative importance, were calculated using hierarchical Bayes, and latent class multinomial logit analyses (LCA) were used to identify distinct preference groups. RESULTS: Of 472 participants (median age 30.0 years, 53.8% female, 9.6 % HIV-positive), 381 (76.4 %) were community members, and 91 (19.3 %) were HCWs. Disease characteristics (specific disease, infection likelihood, severity) and vaccine characteristics (efficacy, protection duration) were the most important factors influencing vaccine decision-making. LCA identified five community member and two HCW groups- all prioritized the specific disease targeted by the vaccine. Community groups included "Personal Health-Focused" (31.0 %, prioritizing disease severity and future vaccine-related health problems), "Disease Protection and Social Awareness" (22.8 %;prioritizing vaccine protection duration, broader social norms), "Incentive Motivated" (18.9 %; prioritizing financial incentives), "Vaccine Cautious" (15.5 %;prioritizing vaccine origin, safety concerns), and "Mandate Motivated" (11.8 %;prioritizing vaccination requirements). HCW groups were, "Disease and Efficacy Driven" (62.6 %;prioritizing vaccine effectiveness, disease severity, side effects) and "Pragmatic Minded " (37.4 %;prioritizing number of doses, protection duration, pregnancy safety). CONCLUSIONS: While disease-specific factors commonly shaped vaccine preferences, heterogeneity among community members and HCWs highlights the need for differentiated delivery and communication strategies that incorporate group-specific motivations and utilize trusted sources to optimize uptake of future adult vaccines in Zambia and other LMICs.
引用
- Le Tourneau N, Sharma A, Pry JM, et al. Drivers of decision-making for future adult vaccines: a best-worst scaling among community members and health care workers in Zambia. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 41319439. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.128003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。