加拿大老年人、城市原住民与新移民的新冠疫苗犹豫定性比较研究
以WHO疫苗犹豫决定因素矩阵为编码框架,识别出疫苗护照与强制接种、历史影响、对政府和卫生当局的信任、感知风险、同伴意见及疫苗风险收益等因素,并揭示各群体背后因素的差异及原住民社区入口路障等文献中少见的方面。
要点
- 疫苗犹豫的决定因素包括疫苗护照与强制接种、历史影响、信任、感知风险、同伴意见及疫苗风险收益。
- 不同群体疫苗犹豫的深层因素存在差异,需针对性设计接种策略。
- 原住民社区入口路障等结构性障碍是文献中较少提及的疫苗犹豫相关方面。
核心结论
- 疫苗犹豫具有复杂性,其背后因素在老年人、城市原住民和新移民群体间存在差异。
- 研究结果可助力制定针对性强且文化安全的疫苗接种规划,尤其适用于新疫苗引入或未来大流行时。
研究设计与样本
- 定性比较研究,属于更大定性项目的一部分,数据已预先收集并转录。
- 纳入分析者分布为老年人36人、城市原住民24人、新移民19人。
- 使用NVivo软件进行主题内容分析,编码以WHO疫苗犹豫决定因素矩阵为指导。
主要发现
- 识别的疫苗犹豫决定因素包括疫苗护照和其他疫苗强制令、健康检查点、历史影响、对政府和卫生当局的信任、对COVID-19的感知风险、同伴意见以及疫苗的风险与收益。
- 研究凸显了疫苗犹豫的复杂性,并表明犹豫的深层因素在不同群体间可有所不同。
- 研究描述了文献中较少涉及的疫苗犹豫方面,如原住民社区入口处的路障和检查点。
临床怎么用
- 可依据不同群体特有的犹豫决定因素,设计针对性强且文化安全的疫苗接种规划。
- 在新疫苗引入或未来大流行应对中,应关注疫苗护照、强制令、信任及结构性障碍等因素对接种意愿的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: As seen during the COVID-19 pandemic, infectious diseases disproportionally affect some subgroups that are often prioritized by publicly funded vaccination programs. Vaccine hesitancy could jeopardize the success of these tailored vaccination efforts. The goal of this study was to explore and compare vaccine hesitancy against COVID-19 in the context of the pandemic in the province of Quebec among three distinct groups: older adults, Indigenous People in urban settings and newcomers. METHODS: This study is part of a larger qualitative project on information practices for which data had already been collected and transcribed. Participants were recruited through a recruitment database and various community organizations. Eighty-four individual interviews were conducted between summer 2021 and spring 2022. A thematic content analysis was conducted using NVivo Software. The coding was guided by the Vaccine Hesitancy Determinants Matrix created by the World Health Organization. RESULTS: Among the 79 interviews included in the analysis, the distribution was as follows: older adults (n = 36), Indigenous People in urban settings (n = 24) and newcomers (n = 19). The identified determinants of vaccine hesitancy included vaccine passport and other vaccines mandates, health checkpoints, historical influences, trust in the government and health authorities, perceived risk around COVID-19, peers' opinions and risks and benefits of the vaccines. The study highlighted vaccine hesitancy's complexity while demonstrating how underlying factors of hesitancy can vary across different groups. The study also depicted aspects of vaccine hesitancy rarely addressed in literature, such as roadblocks and checkpoints at the entrance of Indigenous communities. CONCLUSION: This qualitative study is one of the few studies exploring and comparing vaccine hesitancy against COVID-19 among older adults, Indigenous People in urban settings and newcomers. The results could contribute to the development of tailored and culturally safe vaccination programs, particularly during the introduction of a new vaccine or in the event of a future pandemic.
引用
- Miron É, Sauvageau C, Dubé E, et al. Vaccine hesitancy among older adults, urban indigenous and newcomers in Canada: A qualitative comparative study. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 41447781. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.128143
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。