科罗拉多州三种卫生系统中成人自报疫苗接种状态的准确性验证
本研究于2021年6月至2022年4月在科罗拉多州三个卫生系统(安全网、整合型、农村)对13,667名≥19岁成人进行疫苗接种调查,以电子健康记录加科罗拉多免疫信息系统的数据为金标准,评估五种成人疫苗自报接种状态的敏感度和特异度。结果显示自报敏感度范围为75.2%(HPV)至90.4%(流感),特异度范围为40.9%(破伤风)至92.9%(带状疱疹),净偏倚范围为-11.0(肺炎球菌)至8.1(流感)。
要点
- 自报HPV接种敏感度最低(75.2%),破伤风特异度最低(40.9%)。
- 非西班牙裔黑人受访者对HPV、流感、破伤风的自报敏感度低于非西班牙裔白人。
- 农村卫生系统流感、破伤风、带状疱疹自报敏感度高于整合型系统。
核心结论
- 自报疫苗接种状态的敏感度和特异度总体较高,但HPV(一生仅接种一剂次)敏感度较低,破伤风(不常接种)特异度较低。
- 这些发现对解读全国调查数据及指导疫苗接种工作具有意义。
研究设计与样本
- 2021年6月至2022年4月在科罗拉多州三个卫生系统(安全网、整合型、农村)开展调查。
- 抽样13,667名≥19岁成人,全部评估流感和破伤风接种状态,19-45岁评估HPV,≥50岁评估带状疱疹,≥65岁评估肺炎球菌。
- 以电子健康记录加科罗拉多免疫信息系统数据为金标准,采用调查加权逻辑回归估计敏感度和特异度。
- 调查应答率为29%。
主要发现
- 自报接种敏感度范围:75.2%(HPV)至90.4%(流感)。
- 自报接种特异度范围:40.9%(破伤风)至92.9%(带状疱疹)。
- 净偏倚范围:-11.0(肺炎球菌,表示低报)至8.1(流感,表示高报)。
- 非西班牙裔黑人受访者对HPV、流感、破伤风的自报敏感度低于非西班牙裔白人。
- 农村卫生系统流感、破伤风、带状疱疹自报敏感度高于整合型系统;农村和安全网卫生系统流感和带状疱疹特异度低于整合型系统。
临床怎么用
- 解读全国疫苗接种调查数据时应考虑自报状态在不同疫苗、人群和卫生系统中的敏感度与特异度差异。
- 利用自报数据指导疫苗接种工作时需注意HPV敏感度较低和破伤风特异度较低可能带来的偏倚。
局限性
- 调查应答率为29%,可能存在无应答偏倚。
- 研究仅纳入科罗拉多州三个卫生系统,外推性受限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccination surveys contribute to understanding coverage among adults, but recent information on self-report accuracy is limited. We aimed to validate vaccination status reported by survey for five adult vaccines. METHODS: Between June 2021 and April 2022, we conducted a survey in three Colorado health systems (safety-net, integrated, rural). We sampled 13,667 adults aged ≥19 years. All were assessed for influenza and tetanus vaccination status; those aged 19-45 years were assessed for HPV, those aged ≥50 years were assessed for zoster, and those aged ≥65 years were assessed for pneumococcal vaccination status. Sensitivity and specificity of self-reported vaccination status were estimated using survey-weighted logistic regression from electronic health record plus Colorado Immunization Information System data as criterion standard. Net bias was defined as coverage based on self-report minus coverage based on the criterion standard. Multivariable models evaluated variation in sensitivity and specificity by respondent and site characteristics. RESULTS: Survey response rate was 29 %. The sensitivity of self-reported vaccination status ranged from 75.2 % (HPV) to 90.4 % (influenza). Specificity varied from 40.9 % (tetanus) to 92.9 % (zoster). Net bias estimates varied from -11.0 (pneumococcal) to 8.1 (influenza) with negative values indicating underreporting and positive values indicating overreporting of vaccination. Sensitivity was lower for Non-Hispanic Black than Non-Hispanic White respondents for HPV, influenza, and tetanus vaccines. Sensitivity was higher in rural than integrated health systems for influenza, tetanus, and zoster vaccines. Additionally, specificity for influenza and zoster vaccines was lower in the rural and the safety-net than the integrated health system. CONCLUSIONS: Although sensitivity and specificity of self-report were relatively high for all vaccines, we observed lower sensitivity for HPV, a vaccination with a single lifetime series, and lower specificity for tetanus, a vaccine given infrequently. These findings have implications for interpreting national survey data and their use to guide vaccine delivery efforts.
引用
- Hurley LP, Crane LA, Daley MF, et al. Accuracy of self-reported vaccination status using surveys in safety-net, integrated and rural health systems in Colorado. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 41371123. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.128101
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。