寻求与授予强制疫苗特殊医疗豁免的经历:范围综述
该范围综述按PRISMA-ScR和JBI方法检索多个数据库,纳入18篇文章,梳理家长、照护者或个体为儿童强制疫苗、医护人员职业疫苗及COVID-19疫苗寻求特殊医疗豁免的经历,以及临床医生评估与授予此类豁免的经历。结果显示特殊医疗豁免授予不一致,申请者多支持广泛接种但表达情境性健康担忧,支持豁免决策的证据常缺乏,对临床医生的信任影响家庭后续疫苗决策,豁免可产生从个体到社区和政策的更广泛影响。结论指出特殊医疗豁免缺乏定义清晰性和标准化标准。
要点
- 特殊医疗豁免的授予不一致,缺乏定义清晰性和标准化标准。
- 寻求特殊医疗豁免者多支持广泛接种,但表达情境特异性健康担忧。
- 关于疫苗如何影响豁免请求所依据医学状况的证据常缺乏,决策存在关键缺口。
核心结论
- 特殊医疗豁免目前缺乏定义清晰性和标准化标准,导致豁免决定不一致且可能不公平。
- 需要更多研究为循证指导提供依据,以平衡公共卫生保护与个体临床复杂性。
- 更清晰的政策框架和临床医生支持对确保公平透明的豁免流程至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 采用PRISMA-ScR和JBI方法开展范围综述。
- 检索数据库包括Embase、Medline、CINAHL、PsycInfo、PubMed、Web of Science和Google Scholar。
- 纳入定性、定量、综述文章和灰色文献,由两名独立评审者在Covidence中完成筛选和数据提取。
- 共18篇文章符合纳入标准,数据分析采用描述性和归纳性内容分析。
主要发现
- 特殊医疗豁免授予不一致。
- 寻求特殊医疗豁免的个体通常支持广泛接种,但表达情境特异性健康担忧。
- 关于疫苗如何影响豁免请求所依据医学状况的证据常缺乏,留下当前标准未解决的关键决策缺口。
- 对优先考虑个体健康需求而非严格政策的临床医生的信任,塑造了家庭后续疫苗决策。
- 特殊医疗豁免可从个体或人际层面产生到更广泛社区和政策层面的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Medical exemptions to mandated vaccines are permitted for contraindications, such as anaphylaxis and immunosuppression. However, clinicians encounter 'special medical exemptions' when the medical reason for requiring an exemption falls outside strict criteria. Processes for seeking, assessing, and granting these exemptions are often unclear and vary across jurisdictions. AIM: To map the published literature on the experiences of parents, caregivers, or individuals seeking special medical exemptions for mandated childhood vaccines, occupational vaccines for healthcare workers, and COVID-19 vaccines, as well as the experiences of clinicians assessing and granting such exemptions globally. METHODS: A scoping review was conducted using PRISMA-ScR and JBI methodology. Databases searched included Embase, Medline, CINAHL, PsycInfo, PubMed, Web of Science, and Google Scholar. Qualitative, quantitative, review articles, and grey literature were included. Screening and data extraction were completed in Covidence by two independent reviewers. Data were analysed using descriptive and inductive content analysis. RESULTS: Eighteen articles met inclusion criteria. Key findings were: (1) special medical exemptions are inconsistently granted; (2) individuals seeking special medical exemptions often support vaccination broadly, but express context-specific health concerns; (3) evidence on how vaccines affect the medical conditions underlying exemption requests were often lacking, leaving key gaps for decision-making not addressed by current criteria; (4) trust in clinicians who prioritised individual health needs over strict policy shaped families' subsequent vaccine decision; and (5) special medical exemptions can have wider implications from an individual or interpersonal level to a broader community and policy level. CONCLUSION: Special medical exemptions currently lack definitional clarity and standardised criteria, leading to inconsistent and potentially inequitable exemption decisions. More research is needed to inform evidence-based guidance that balances public health protection with individual clinical complexity. Clearer policy frameworks and clinician support are essential to ensure fair and transparent exemptions processes.
引用
- Devsam B, Bortolussi K, Tippins J, et al. The experience of seeking & granting special medical exemptions for mandated vaccines: A scoping review. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 41237540. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127935
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。