公众对COVID-19疫苗的信任与不信任:一项系统性元叙事综述
该系统性元叙事综述纳入79项同行评议研究,分析公众对COVID-19疫苗信任的概念化、操作化及其与接种的关系。研究发现多数为欧美定量调查,信任多通过Likert量表测量对科学、科学家、公共卫生机构和疫苗的态度;态度性和 contingent 信任主导文献,认知与情感维度探索不足。结论认为信任并非单一构念,而是由情境、沟通和经验塑造的相互关联的态度与判断集合。
要点
- 多数研究为欧美定量调查,信任常以Likert量表测量对科学、科学家、公共卫生机构和疫苗的态度。
- 态度性和 contingent 信任主导文献,认知与情感维度探索不足。
- 信任的指涉对象从机构、信息来源到个人倾向和社会动态差异广泛。
核心结论
- 元叙事方法为综合概念多元主义提供了有价值工具。
- 研究提示疫苗接种信任并非单一构念,而是由情境、沟通和经验塑造的相互关联的态度与判断集合,每项均对公共卫生有启示。
研究设计与样本
- 系统性元叙事综述,检索关于信任/不信任、科学与COVID-19疫苗的文献。
- 最终样本包括79项关于COVID-19疫苗接种信任的同行评议研究。
- 识别各研究领域、目的、方法和样本量,并归纳/演绎探索先前研究提出的六种信任叙事:态度性、认知性、情感性、 contingent、情境性和沟通性。
主要发现
- 多数为在欧洲和美国进行的定量调查式研究,信任通常通过评估对科学、科学家、公共卫生当局和疫苗本身态度的Likert量表测量。
- 尽管几乎所有研究将信任视为关键解释因素,但其指涉对象差异广泛,从机构和信息来源到个人倾向和社会动态。
- 信任的影响范围从接种意愿和动机到犹豫和实际接种。
- 元叙事框架突出态度性和 contingent 信任主导文献,而认知和情感维度主要探索不足。
- 尽管定量方法占主导,这种标准化提供了可比性和政策相关性的优势,但对信任的情感、关系和沟通方面探索有限,错失了更细致理解的机会。
局限性
- 对信任的情感、关系和沟通方面探索有限,错失了更细致理解的机会。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Trust played a fundamental role in vaccine decision-making and uptake during the COVID-19 pandemic. The purpose of this study is to explore how public trust was conceptualized, operationalized, and implicated in vaccine uptake research on COVID-19 vaccines. METHODS: Using a systematic meta-narrative review, we searched literature around trust/distrust, science and COVID-19 vaccines. This involved identifying research areas, aims, methods, and sample sizes for each study while inductively/deductively exploring six narratives of trust - attitudinal, cognitive, affective, contingent, contextual, and communicated - developed in a previous study to synthesize findings across diverse disciplines and methodologies. RESULTS: The final sample consisted of 79 peer-reviewed studies on trust in relation to COVID-19 vaccination. Our analysis revealed a degree of methodological uniformity as most were quantitative survey-based investigations conducted in Europe and the United States with trust typically operationalized through Likert-scale measures assessing attitudes toward science, scientists, public health authorities, and the vaccines themselves. Conceptual diversity was also evident as although trust was treated as a key explanatory factor in nearly all studies, its referents varied widely, from institutions and information sources to personal dispositions and social dynamics. Similarly, the implications of trust ranged from vaccination intention and motivation to hesitancy and actual uptake. The meta-narrative framework highlighted that attitudinal and contingent trust dominated the literature, while cognitive and affective dimensions were mainly underexplored. Despite the methodological dominance of quantitative approaches, this standardization offers strengths of comparability and policy relevance, but the limited exploration of emotional, relational, and communicative aspects of trust points to missed opportunities for more nuanced understanding. CONCLUSION: The meta-narrative approach provided a valuable tool for synthesizing conceptual pluralism. Our findings suggest that trust in vaccination is not a singular construct, but a constellation of interrelated attitudes and judgments shaped by context, communication, and experience, each with implications for public health.
引用
- Ledderer L, Nielsen KH, Skodborg L, et al. Public trust and mistrust of COVID-19 vaccines: A systematic meta-narrative review. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 41218570. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127947
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。