欧洲移民人群的疫苗犹豫:一项混合方法系统综述
本系统综述检索8个数据库2000年1月至2024年12月英文或法文原始研究,纳入46项研究(20项定性、26项定量),采用JBI混合方法系统综述方法学与MMAT质量评价,围绕文化适应、对当局不信任、健康素养、非正式信息网络、社会文化决定因素、社会人口学特征和疫苗特异性认知七个整合主题综合欧洲移民疫苗犹豫证据。
要点
- 欧洲移民疫苗犹豫反映原籍国信念、东道国规范与移民相关脆弱性的交互作用。
- 性别化约束、有限健康素养、非正式信息网络和持续的制度不信任强化疫苗犹豫。
- 作者建议与移民社区共同设计文化响应性、参与式干预,并关注制度不信任与性别约束。
核心结论
- 欧洲移民的疫苗犹豫反映原籍国信念、东道国社会规范与移民相关脆弱性的交互作用,并受性别化约束、有限健康素养、非正式信息网络和持续制度不信任的强化。
- 作者认为应对这些决定因素需要与移民社区共同设计的文化响应性、参与式干预,契合健康素养需求并关注制度不信任与性别化约束。
- 作者提出进一步研究应考察代表性不足群体、性别与移民及信任的交互作用以及代际间态度演变,以指导可持续的信任建立策略。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法系统综述,检索PubMed/MEDLINE、PsycINFO、EMBASE、Scopus、CINAHL、Web of Science、ERIC和Cochrane Library 8个数据库2000年1月至2024年12月发表的英文或法文原始研究,并手工检索相关非原始研究的参考文献。
- 遵循Joanna Briggs Institute(JBI)混合方法系统综述方法学,纳入探索欧洲移民人群疫苗态度的合格研究,采用混合方法评价工具(MMAT)评价纳入研究质量,使用JBI混合方法数据提取表提取数据,并采用汇聚整合方法进行综合。
- 共纳入46项研究(20项定性研究和26项定量研究),多数在西欧或北欧开展,考察包括合法与无证件个体在内的多样化移民人群。
主要发现
- 证据综合为七个整合发现:(1)文化适应;(2)对当局的不信任;(3)健康素养;(4)非正式信息网络;(5)社会文化决定因素;(6)社会人口学特征;(7)疫苗特异性认知。
- 未因质量排除任何研究,但MMAT评分用于指导解释。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应对这些决定因素需要与移民社区共同设计的文化响应性、参与式干预,契合健康素养需求并关注制度不信任与性别化约束。
- 作者提出进一步研究应考察代表性不足群体、性别与移民及信任的交互作用以及代际间态度演变,以指导可持续的信任建立策略。
局限性
- 多数纳入研究在西欧或北欧开展,证据地理分布有限。
- 作者指出进一步研究应考察代表性不足群体、性别与移民及信任的交互作用以及代际间态度演变。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Among migrants, vaccine uptake is influenced by various factors including interrupted vaccination in origin countries, divergent schedules, and marginalization within host systems. Vaccine hesitancy is shaped by cultural, structural, and experiential factors that differ from native-born populations. This systematic review aims to synthesize qualitative and quantitative evidence on vaccine hesitancy among migrant populations in Europe. METHODS: Eight databases (PubMed/MEDLINE, PsycINFO, EMBASE, Scopus, CINAHL, Web of Science, ERIC, and Cochrane Library) were searched for primary studies published in English or French between January 2000 and December 2024. References from relevant non-primary studies were hand-searched. This review followed the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) methodology for mixed-methods systematic reviews. Eligible studies explored vaccine attitudes among migrant populations in Europe. The quality of included studies was assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT). Data extraction used JBI's Mixed Methods Data Extraction Form, and synthesis followed a convergent integrated approach. RESULTS: Forty-six studies were included (20 qualitative and 26 quantitative), most conducted in Western or Northern Europe and examining diverse migrant populations including legal and undocumented individuals. Evidence was synthesized under seven integrated findings: (1) acculturation, (2) distrust in authorities, (3) health literacy, (4) informal information networks, (5) sociocultural determinants, (6) sociodemographic characteristics and (7) vaccine-specific perceptions. No studies were excluded based on quality, but MMAT scores informed interpretation. CONCLUSION: Vaccine hesitancy among migrants in Europe reflects the interplay of origin-country beliefs, host-society norms, and migration-related vulnerabilities, reinforced by gendered constraints, limited health literacy, informal information networks, and persistent institutional mistrust. Addressing these determinants requires culturally responsive, participatory interventions co-designed with migrant communities, tailored to health literacy needs, and attentive to institutional mistrust and gendered constraints. Further research should examine underrepresented groups, the interaction of gender, migration, and trust, and evolving attitudes across generations to guide sustainable confidence-building strategies.
引用
- Khuu E, Moussaoui S, Vignier N, et al. Vaccine hesitancy among migrant populations in Europe: A mixed-methods systematic review. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 41202609. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127954
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。