宗教传统对疫苗接种率呈现异质性影响:一项支持定制化健康外展的美国县级回归分析
本研究匹配2021—2022年美国县级COVID-19疫苗接种数据与2020年美国宗教普查中6大宗教传统的构成数据,采用负二项回归分析宗教归属与接种率的关联。结果显示天主教和主流新教人群与接种率呈显著正相关(分别+12.4%和+25.1%),福音派新教人群呈显著负相关(-12.9%),共和党投票偏好是所有宗教传统中最强的预测因素(系数范围-55.6%至-93.7%)。作者认为公共卫生外展应考虑特定宗教传统的背景,而非将宗教视为单一变量。
要点
- 天主教和主流新教人群与COVID-19疫苗接种率呈显著正相关(分别+12.4%和+25.1%)。
- 福音派新教人群与接种率呈显著负相关(-12.9%),共和党投票偏好为最强预测因素。
- 摩门教、黑人新教和穆斯林人群未显示显著关联,包括全国和区域分析。
核心结论
- 宗教传统通过有限但显著的群体特异性过程影响预防性健康措施。
- 教会—教派定位部分解释了这些模式,历史上文化融合的传统比保持文化张力的传统对疫苗接种表现出更高的接受度。
- 鉴于宗教传统间关联的差异,公共卫生外展方法应考虑特定宗教传统的背景,而非仅将宗教视为单一变量。
研究设计与样本
- 研究匹配2021—2022年美国县级COVID-19疫苗接种数据与2020年美国宗教普查中6大宗教传统的宗教构成数据。
- 采用负二项回归分析宗教归属与疫苗接种率的关联,并控制其他变量。
主要发现
- 天主教人群与疫苗接种率呈显著正相关(+12.4%)。
- 主流新教人群与疫苗接种率呈显著正相关(+25.1%)。
- 福音派新教人群与疫苗接种率呈显著负相关(-12.9%)。
- 控制包括政治意识形态在内的其他变量后关联持续存在,共和党投票偏好是所有宗教传统中最强的预测因素(系数范围-55.6%至-93.7%)。
- 摩门教、黑人新教和穆斯林人群未显示显著关联,包括全国和区域特异性分析。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,鉴于宗教传统间关联的差异,公共卫生外展方法应考虑特定宗教传统的背景,而非仅将宗教视为单一变量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: This study examines whether specific religious traditions-rather than just religion itself-demonstrate significant associations with COVID-19 vaccination rates. METHODS: County-level COVID-19 vaccination data (2021-2022) were matched with religious composition data from the 2020 U.S. Religion Census for 6 major religious traditions. The analysis uses negative binomial regression to examine how religious adherence is associated with vaccination rates, controlling for other variables. RESULTS: Catholic and Mainline Protestant populations showed significant positive associations with vaccination rates (+12.4% and +25.1% respectively), whereas Evangelical Protestant populations demonstrated significant negative associations (-12.9%). Associations persisted when controlling for other variables, including political ideology, with Republican voting preference emerging as the strongest predictor across all religious traditions (coefficients ranging from -55.6% to -93.7%). Mormon, Black Protestant, and Muslim populations showed no significant associations, including in national and region-specific analyses. CONCLUSIONS: Religious traditions influence preventive health measures through limited but significant group-specific processes. Church-sect positioning partially explains these patterns, with historically culturally integrated traditions showing greater receptivity to vaccination than those maintaining some cultural tension. Given the contrasts in associations across religious traditions, public health outreach approaches should consider the context of specific religious traditions rather than merely approaching religion as a monolithic variable.
引用
- Anderson CA, Zhou S, Chi G, et al. Religious Traditions Exhibit Heterogeneous Effects on Vaccination Uptake: A U.S. County-Level Regression Analysis Supporting Tailored Health Outreach. Am J Prev Med. 2025. PMID: 41067547. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2025.108139
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。