建模实践、数据提供、共享与传播需求用于大流行决策:2020至2022年基于欧洲调查的建模者视角
该研究对欧洲某大型流行病情报联盟的建模者开展两阶段半定量调查,分析2020至2022年新冠疫情期间建模实践、数据使用与决策者互动的演变。样本包括4个欧洲国家11家机构的66项建模贡献,发现传统监测数据近实时可得,但非传统数据(如社会接触与行为调查)和血清学数据常报告缺乏,且不足半数研究公开共享代码。
要点
- 调查覆盖4国11机构共66项建模贡献,按疫情早期、中期和晚期分阶段描述分析。
- 传统监测数据(如病例行列表)广泛近实时可得,非传统数据与血清学数据常报告缺乏。
- 与决策者频繁双向互动塑造了建模范围与建议,但不足半数研究共享开放获取代码。
核心结论
- 研究凸显公共卫生危机期间建模的使用与需求不断演变,非传统数据可得性的持续缺口凸显需重新思考可持续的数据收集与共享实践,包括来自营利性提供方的数据。
- 未来防范应聚焦加强协作平台、研究联盟和建模网络,以促进数据与代码共享及学术界、决策者与数据提供方之间的有效协作。
研究设计与样本
- 对欧洲某大型流行病情报联盟的建模者开展两阶段半定量调查,按疫情早期、中期和晚期阶段对回答进行描述性分析。
- 样本包括来自4个欧洲国家11家机构的66项建模贡献。
- 使用Overton中的政策引用评估政策影响。
主要发现
- COVID-19建模最初优先理解流行动力学,随后评估非药物干预和疫苗接种影响变得同等重要。
- 传统监测数据(如病例行列表)广泛近实时可得。
- 实时非传统数据(尤其是社会接触与行为调查)和血清学数据常报告缺乏。
- 数据缺口包括分层不佳和地理覆盖不完整。
- 与决策者频繁双向互动塑造了建模范围与建议,但不足半数研究共享开放获取代码。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUNDAdvanced outbreak analytics were instrumental in informing governmental decision-making during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, systematic evaluations of how modelling practices, data use and science-policy interactions evolved during this and previous emergencies remain scarce.AIMThis study assessed the evolution of modelling practices, data usage, gaps, and engagement between modellers and decision-makers to inform future global epidemic intelligence.METHODSWe conducted a two-stage semiquantitative survey among modellers in a large European epidemic intelligence consortium. Responses were analysed descriptively across early, mid- and late-pandemic phases. We used policy citations in Overton to assess policy impact.RESULTSOur sample included 66 modelling contributions from 11 institutions in four European countries. COVID-19 modelling initially prioritised understanding epidemic dynamics; evaluating non-pharmaceutical interventions and vaccination impacts later became equally important. Traditional surveillance data (e.g. case line lists) were widely available in near-real time. Conversely, real-time non-traditional data (notably social contact and behavioural surveys) and serological data were frequently reported as lacking. Gaps included poor stratification and incomplete geographical coverage. Frequent bidirectional engagement with decision-makers shaped modelling scope and recommendations. However, fewer than half of the studies shared open-access code.CONCLUSIONSWe highlight the evolving use and needs of modelling during public health crises. Persistent gaps in the availability of non-traditional data underscore the need to rethink sustainable data collection and sharing practices, including from for-profit providers. Future preparedness should focus on strengthening collaborative platforms, research consortia and modelling networks to foster data and code sharing and effective collaboration between academia, decision-makers and data providers.
引用
- van Kleef E, Van Bortel W, Arsevska E, et al. Modelling practices, data provisioning, sharing and dissemination needs for pandemic decision-making: a European survey-based modellers' perspective, 2020 to 2022. Euro Surveill. 2025. PMID: 41133306. doi:10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2025.30.42.2500216
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。