中低收入国家提高常规儿童疫苗接种率的多组分干预措施范围综述
该范围综述检索中低收入国家提高常规儿童疫苗 uptake 的多组分干预研究,纳入70篇文章共79项干预(35项随机、44项准实验)。包含激励、支持或技能培训以及针对多个社会生态层面群体的干预更有效,但干预组分数量与效果无关,仅2/79项使用评估框架、44%评估了实施结局。
要点
- 纳入79项多组分干预,其中35项随机、44项准实验。
- 含激励、支持或技能培训及针对多层面群体的干预更有效。
- 干预组分数量与效果无关,无明确最佳组分组合。
核心结论
- 详细报告干预并纳入由评估框架指导的实施结局,将帮助中低收入国家决策者识别、调整并成功实施有效干预以提高常规儿童疫苗接种率。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循乔安娜布里格斯研究所方法学,检索同行评议与灰色文献数据库中旨在提高中低收入国家常规儿童疫苗 uptake 的多组分干预研究。
- 由一名作者筛选标题和摘要并提取数据,另一名作者核对10%的研究。
- 从7613条参考文献中纳入70篇文章,报告79项多组分干预(35项随机和44项准实验)。
- 开发并应用了干预组分目的分类法,用计数和频率总结纳入研究,并将实施结局映射至Proctor实施结局框架。
主要发现
- 包含激励、支持或技能培训的多组分干预以及针对不同社会生态层面多个群体的干预在提高疫苗 uptake 方面更有效。
- 更多干预组分与效果改善不相关,且没有明确模式表明最有效的组分组合。
- 少数干预(2/79;3%)使用了评估框架,44%(35/79)在效果之外评估了实施结局。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Most under- and unvaccinated children live in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), but robust synthesised evidence about interventions to improve routine childhood vaccine uptake in these settings is limited. Systematic reviews generally focus on effectiveness, rather than implementation, and often exclude quasi-randomised studies and multicomponent interventions, which are common in LMICs. We aimed to synthesise the literature from LMICs that may be missed in traditional systematic reviews. OBJECTIVES: This review aimed to identify, compare, and summarise the properties, reported effects, evaluation methods and implementation outcomes of multicomponent interventions to improve uptake of routine childhood vaccines in LMICs. METHODS: Following Joanna Briggs Institute methodology, we searched peer reviewed and grey literature databases for intervention studies with more than one component i.e., purpose or format of delivery, aiming to improve routine childhood vaccine uptake in a LMIC. One author screened titles and abstracts and extracted data, with another author checking 10 % of studies. We developed and applied a taxonomy of intervention component purposes. Counts and frequencies were used to summarise the included studies. Where measured, we mapped implementation outcomes to Proctor's Implementation Outcomes Framework. RESULTS: From 7613 references, we identified 70 articles reporting on 79 multicomponent interventions (35 randomised and 44 quasi-experimental). Multicomponent interventions including incentives, support, or skills training, and those targeting multiple groups at different socioecological levels were more effective at increasing vaccine uptake. More intervention components did not correlate with improved effectiveness, and there was no clear pattern indicating the most effective combination of components. Few interventions (2/79; 3 %) used an evaluation framework, and 44 % (35/79) evaluated an implementation outcome in addition to effectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: Detailed reporting of interventions and the inclusion of implementation outcomes guided by evaluation frameworks will help decision-makers in LMICs to identify, adapt, and successfully implement effective interventions to improve routine childhood vaccine uptake. REGISTRATION DETAILS: https://osf.io/7r84g.
引用
- Mohamed Y, Danchin M, Boyd L, et al. A scoping review of multicomponent interventions to improve uptake of routine childhood vaccines in low- and middle-income countries. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40934734. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127727
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。