中国社区护士新冠疫苗接种障碍与道德挣扎:批判医学人类学分析
该研究采用定性描述方法,于2022年9月至12月对香港35名未接种新冠疫苗的护士进行半结构化深度访谈,依据批判医学人类学框架进行主题分析。识别出接种障碍与不接种的道德挣扎两个主题,涉及同事及非医务人员经社交媒体传播的负面信息、对政府和工作场所疫苗政策及疫苗商业盈利性质的不信任,以及对抗新冠感染的中医药疗效的文化信心。作者认为针对不同社会层面影响护士社会化过程的因素对促进疫苗接受至关重要。
要点
- 对香港35名未接种新冠疫苗护士的深度访谈识别出接种障碍与不接种的道德挣扎两个主题。
- 护士因同事及非医务人员经社交媒体传播的负面信息而对疫苗缺乏信心并担忧个人安全。
- 护士对政府和工作场所疫苗政策及疫苗商业盈利性质存在不信任,并对中医药抗新冠感染疗效有文化信心。
核心结论
- 个体层面上,参与者缺乏信心和担忧疫苗安全源于同事及非医务人员经社交媒体传播的负面信息在个体与微观社会层面的交织关系。
- 中间社会层面可见对资本主义运作盈利性质的不信任,宏观社会层面可见对抗新冠感染的中医药疗效的文化信心。
- 作者认为依据批判医学人类学框架针对不同社会层面影响护士社会化过程的因素,对促进护士疫苗接受至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 定性描述研究,于2022年9月至12月对香港35名未接种新冠疫苗的护士进行半结构化深度访谈。
- 依据批判医学人类学框架对数据进行主题分析。
主要发现
- 识别出两个主题:接种新冠疫苗的障碍与参与者不接种的道德挣扎。
- 参与者表现出缺乏信心和个人安全担忧,与同事及非医务人员经社交媒体分享的负面信息有关。
- 参与者对政府和工作场所的疫苗接种政策表现出抵制,并不信任新冠疫苗的商业和盈利导向性质。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Past studies have shown that people are less inclined to get vaccinated when healthcare providers are hesitant about the immunisation. Nurses have been documented as the most hesitant healthcare group towards COVID-19 vaccination in both Western and Chinese communities. This study investigates the perceptions of COVID-19 vaccines among nurses in a Chinese society and the reasons contributing to their high hesitancy. METHODS: A qualitative descriptive approach was used, involving in-depth semi-structured interviews from September to December 2022 with 35 nurses in Hong Kong who did not receive COVID-19 vaccinations. A thematic analysis of the data was implemented in accordance with the critical medical anthropology framework. RESULTS: Two themes were identified: barriers to receiving COVID-19 vaccinations and the moral struggles of participants in not getting vaccinated. Participants demonstrated a lack of confidence and individual safety concerns, related to the negative information shared among their healthcare colleagues and non-healthcare workers through social media platforms. Participants revealed resistance towards the vaccination policies of the government and their workplaces, and they distrusted the commercial and profit-oriented nature of the vaccines against COVID-19. CONCLUSION: At the individual level, participants' lack of confidence and worries about vaccine safety emerged from the intertwined relationship of the negative information shared among their healthcare colleagues and non-healthcare workers through social media platforms at both the individual and micro-social levels. In addition, resistance was seen at the intermediate-social level, involving distrust of the profit-oriented nature of the capitalist operation, as well as cultural confidence in the efficacy of traditional Chinese medicine against COVID-19 infection at the macro-social level. This study suggests that addressing the agents that can affect nurses' socialisation process at different social levels according to the critical medical anthropology framework is crucial for motivating nurses' vaccine acceptance.
引用
- Siu JY. Barriers to COVID-19 vaccinations and moral struggle among nurses in a Chinese community: A critical medical anthropology analysis. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40773964. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127574
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。