文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

不同疫苗,不同信任问题?使用优势分析解构对各类机构信任的影响

Different vaccines, different trust issues? Disentangling the effect of trust in various institutions using dominance analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2025-08-27

该研究基于2023年夏季对法国成年人口(n=4303,配额抽样并事后分层加权)的调查,使用优势分析比较对13类机构和行为者的不信任对多种疫苗态度的影响。发现对科学的信任总体上对各类疫苗态度均是重要决定因素,对政府机构和制药公司的信任也至关重要;对科学信任的重要性因疫苗而异,对一般疫苗接种和麻疹疫苗态度影响尤大,而对政治行为者的信任和政治倾向对新冠疫苗接种态度影响更大。

要点

  • 对科学的信任是影响所有疫苗态度的重要决定因素。
  • 对政府机构和制药公司的信任对疫苗态度也至关重要。
  • 对科学信任的重要性因疫苗而异,对新冠更依赖政治信任。

核心结论

  • 对科学的信任总体上是所有疫苗态度的重要决定因素,对政府机构和制药公司的信任也至关重要。
  • 对科学信任的重要性因疫苗而异:对一般疫苗接种和麻疹疫苗接种态度影响尤大,而对政治行为者的信任和政治倾向对新冠疫苗接种态度影响更大。
  • 研究强调干预措施需针对每种疫苗的具体特点量身定制,并强调机构决策过程需保证疫苗接种政策的循证性质。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究基于2023年夏季在法国成年人口中开展的一项调查,样本量n=4303,采用配额抽样并事后分层加权。
  • 调查包含与疫苗接种(一般疫苗接种及新冠、麻疹、HPV、乙肝和流感疫苗接种)相关的丰富问题,以及涉及对13类机构和行为者信任的一组条目(CEVIPOF信任晴雨表)。
  • 使用优势分析比较对每个机构和行为者的不信任对多种疫苗及一般疫苗接种态度的影响,并与疫苗犹豫的其他决定因素(如社会经济地位、政治认同和科学素养)进行比较。

主要发现

  • 总体上,对科学的信任倾向于成为对所有疫苗态度的重要决定因素。
  • 对政府机构和制药公司的信任也至关重要。
  • 对科学信任的重要性因疫苗而异:对一般疫苗接种和麻疹疫苗接种态度影响尤大,而对政治行为者的信任和政治倾向对新冠疫苗接种态度影响更大。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Vaccination campaigns involve a wide variety of institutional actors whether as producers of expertise, as decision-makers or as organizers and vaccinators. In this paper, we aim to compare the role of trust in a variety of institutions and actors on attitudes to vaccines in France, with a particular focus on the role of trust in scientific and political actors. We draw on a survey conducted in the summer of 2023 among a large sample of the French adult population (n = 4303, quota sampling with post-stratification weighting procedure). The survey combines a rich set of questions pertaining to vaccination (vaccination in general and vaccination against Covid-19, Measles, HPV, Hepatitis B and the Flu) as well as a set of items pertaining to trust in 13 institutions and actors (the CEVIPOF Trust Barometer). We use dominance analysis to compare the influence of distrust in each institution and actor on attitudes to a diversity vaccines and vaccination in general. We also compare them to other determinants of vaccine hesitancy such as sociodemographic status, political identities and scientific literacy. We find that, overall, trust in science tends to be an important determinant of attitudes to all vaccines. But we also found that trust in government agencies, and pharmaceutical companies are also crucial. We also found that the importance of trust in science varies depending on the vaccine: it bears particularly heavily on attitudes to vaccination in general and to vaccination against measles while trust in more political actors and political dispositions bear more heavily on attitudes to Covid-19 vaccination. Our study underlines the importance of tayloring interventions to the specificities faced by each vaccine as well as emphasizing how institutional decision-making processes guarantee the evidence-based nature of vaccination policies.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ward JK, Youssef R, Peretti-Watel P, et al. Different vaccines, different trust issues? Disentangling the effect of trust in various institutions using dominance analysis. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40876136. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127668

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。