不同疫苗辟谣干预措施:一项随机对照实验评估「适得其反」与正面效应
该预注册、嵌入调查的实验随机比较三种纠正疫苗错误信息的消息结构(先谣后实、先实后谣再实、仅事实)与无消息对照对新冠疫苗初始接种或加强针意愿的影响。样本限定为对疫苗安全性有担忧的美国成年人,共纳入892名种族与族裔多样化的成年人。结果显示,在已接种初始新冠疫苗者中,先谣后实结构相比对照组与加强针意愿增强相关(B=0.81,p<.01);在尚未开始初始接种者中,三种纠正信息条件与对照组相比启动接种意愿强度无差异;无结果支持辟谣会「适得其反」的担忧。
要点
- 在已接种初始新冠疫苗者中,先谣后实消息结构与对照组相比加强针意愿增强相关(B=0.81,p<.01)。
- 在尚未开始初始接种者中,三种纠正信息条件与对照组相比启动接种意愿强度无差异。
- 无结果支持辟谣会「适得其反」的担忧,因为意愿未被削弱。
核心结论
- 无结果支持辟谣会「适得其反」的担忧,因为意愿未被削弱;先谣后实消息结构显著增强意愿,但仅在已接种初始疫苗组中;另两种辟谣方法对接种意愿无影响。
研究设计与样本
- 预注册、嵌入调查的随机对照实验,样本限定为对疫苗安全性有担忧的美国成年人,共纳入892名种族与族裔多样化的成年人。
- 参与者随机分配至无消息对照组或三种消息结构条件之一:先谣后实、先实后谣再实、仅事实。
- 使用有序逻辑回归模型检验条件对接种意愿的影响。
主要发现
- 在已接种初始新冠疫苗者中,先谣后实消息结构与对照组相比与加强针意愿增强相关(B=0.81,p<.01)。
- 在尚未开始初始新冠疫苗系列者中,三种纠正信息条件与对照组相比启动接种意愿强度无差异。
- 另两种辟谣方法(先实后谣再实、仅事实)对接种意愿无影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Misinformation about vaccines can hinder efforts to increase immunization rates. Attempts to correct misinformation often use one of three common message structures. The effectiveness of these message structures is unclear, and concerns have been raised that some can "backfire" by weakening vaccination intentions. METHODS: We conducted a pre-registered, survey-embedded experiment to test the effect of three different misinformation-correction message structures on vaccine intentions to receive an initial Covid-19 vaccine or booster. The sample was limited to U.S. adults with vaccination safety concerns. Participants were randomized to either a no-message control arm or one of three message structure conditions: (1) a myth followed by fact; (2) a fact, followed by a myth, and then fact again; (3) or fact only. Participants reported their intentions to receive the Covid-19 initial vaccination or booster and, using ordinal logistic regression models, we examined the effect of condition on intentions. RESULTS: The experiment included a group (n = 892) of racially and ethnically diverse adults. Among those who had received initial Covid-19 vaccination, exposure to the myth-followed-by-fact message structure was associated with strengthened booster intentions compared to the control (B = 0.81, p < .01). Among those who had not begun the initial Covid-19 vaccination series, the strength of intention to start vaccination did not differ between the control condition in any of the three misinformation-correction conditions. CONCLUSIONS: Despite fears that debunking can "backfire," none of the results support that concern because intentions were not weakened. The myth-followed-by-fact message structure significantly strengthen intentions, but only among the group that had received the initial vaccination. The two other debunking approaches had no effect on vaccination intentions.
引用
- Morgan JC, Kornides ML, Lee J, et al. Different vaccination debunking interventions: a randomized, controlled experiment estimating "backfiring" and positive effects. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40882577. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127463
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。