四个中低收入国家(几内亚、洪都拉斯、卢旺达和坦桑尼亚)电子免疫登记和电子物流管理信息系统的影响
在几内亚、洪都拉斯、卢旺达和坦桑尼亚四个中低收入国家开展电子免疫登记(eIR)和电子物流管理信息系统(eLMIS)评估,采用目的抽样、半结构化问卷、标准化能力评估和数据准确性检查,于2021年10月至2022年9月收集数据。结果显示用户满意度达87%,81%的eIR用户认为流程效率改善,89%认为免疫服务提供改善;卢旺达和坦桑尼亚纯纸或纯电子环境数据准确性(60%)高于纸质-电子双系统(45%)。
要点
- 用户对eIR和eLMIS工具满意度达87%,非洲国家95%用户重视信息可及性。
- 81%的eIR用户报告流程效率改善,89%报告免疫服务提供改善。
- 卢旺达和坦桑尼亚纯纸或纯电子环境数据准确性60%,高于双系统45%。
核心结论
- 要充分发挥电子工具在中低收入国家的潜力,政府的全面主导、有针对性的基础设施投资、向全电子系统迁移以及eIR与CRVS的整合至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 在几内亚、洪都拉斯、卢旺达和坦桑尼亚四个中低收入国家进行目的性抽样,选取地区、县和卫生机构,基于预设标准。
- 于2021年10月至2022年9月期间,在几内亚50家、洪都拉斯88家、卢旺达36家、坦桑尼亚101家卫生机构收集原始数据,使用半结构化问卷、标准化能力评估和数据准确性检查。
- 数据分析结合定量和定性方法,关注电子工具使用、用户体验、基础设施、人力需求、决策以及免疫数据质量和卫生工作者及疫苗接种者的认知。
主要发现
- eIR和eLMIS的实施与NIP流程和结果的改善相关,用户满意度达87%,非洲国家95%的用户重视信息可及性,91%认为信息准确完整。
- 部分照护者报告使用工具的卫生机构组织更好且等待时间更短;81%的eIR用户注意到流程效率改善,89%注意到免疫服务提供改善。
- 在卢旺达和坦桑尼亚,纯纸或纯电子环境的数据准确性(60%)高于纸质-电子双系统(45%)。
- eLMIS使用与疫苗库存数据质量改善和缺货减少相关;77%的卫生工作者具备数字素养,但数字基础设施不足是工具使用的主要障碍。
- 与民事登记和生命统计系统(CRVS)的互操作性有限,阻碍了未免疫儿童的追踪。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is increasing interest in low-and middle-income countries (LMICs) to introduce and scale-up digital health tools like electronic immunization registries (eIR), and electronic logistics management information systems (eLMIS) to support immunization services. An evaluation of the use of these tools was conducted in four LMICs to inform decisions about their further expansion and investments. METHODS: Purposive sampling of regions, districts, and health facilities was done in each country based on predefined criteria. Primary data were collected between October 2021 and September 2022 in 50 health facilities in Guinea, 88 in Honduras, 36 in Rwanda, and 101 in Tanzania using semi-structured questionnaires, standardized competency assessments and data accuracy checks. Data focused on electronic tool usage, user experience, infrastructure, workforce needs, and decision-making, as well as immunization data quality and perceptions of health workers and vaccine recipients. Data analysis combined both quantitative and qualitative methods. FINDINGS: The implementation of eIR and eLMIS was associated with improvements in National Immunization Programme (NIP) processes and outcomes. Users were satisfied with the tools (87 % satisfaction rate), and 95 % of users in the African countries valued the accessibility of information, with 91 % finding it accurate and complete. Some caregivers reported better organization and shorter waiting times in health facilities using the tools. Most eIR users noted improvements in process efficiencies (81 %) and immunization service delivery (89 %). In Rwanda and Tanzania data accuracy was higher in exclusively paper or electronic settings (60 %) compared to dual paper-electronic systems (45 %). eLMIS use was associated with improvements in vaccine stock data quality and reduced stock-outs. While 77 % of health workers were digitally literate, inadequate digital infrastructure was a key barrier to tool use. Interoperability with the Civil Registration and Vital Statistics system (CRVS) was limited, hindering the tracking of unimmunized children. CONCLUSIONS: To fully realize the potential of electronic tools in LMICs, full government ownership, targeted infrastructure investments, migration to fully electronic systems, and the integration of eIR with the CRVS will be essential.
引用
- Mantel C, Hugo C, Federici C, et al. Impact of electronic immunization registries and electronic logistics management information systems in four low-and middle-income countries: Guinea, Honduras, Rwanda, and Tanzania. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40179523. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。