社交媒体上疫苗错误信息纠正的社会影响
该在线随机研究纳入720名参与者,在假设性大流行情境下比较用户生成纠正与算法纠正对疫苗接种社会规范感知和疫苗意愿的影响。用户生成纠正显著提升认为拒绝接种在社会上非常不恰当及认同疫苗安全性的感知,算法纠正未影响社会规范感知。两种纠正均有助于维持参与者初始较高的疫苗意愿,算法纠正效果更强,而仅接触错误信息的对照组意愿显著下降。
要点
- 用户生成纠正显著提升拒绝接种社会不适当感及疫苗安全共识感知。
- 算法纠正未影响社会规范感知,但维持疫苗意愿效果更强。
- 两种纠正均未显著改变对他人接种意愿的经验预期。
核心结论
- 用户生成纠正重塑疫苗接种的社会规范感知,而引用可信来源的算法纠正可能更好地维持个人较高的疫苗意愿。
研究设计与样本
- 在线随机研究,纳入720名参与者,在假设性大流行情境下评估用户生成纠正或算法纠正对感知社会规范及自身疫苗意愿的影响。
主要发现
- 用户生成纠正显著增加认为拒绝接种在社会上非常不恰当的感知,并增加支持疫苗安全的共识感知。
- 算法纠正未影响社会规范感知。
- 用户生成纠正和算法纠正均未显著改变对他人接种意愿的经验预期。
- 两种纠正均有助于维持参与者初始较高的疫苗意愿,算法纠正效果更强,而仅接触错误信息未获纠正的对照组疫苗意愿显著下降。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This study examines the impact of social versus algorithmic corrections of vaccine misinformation on social media, on the perceptions of social norms around vaccination and vaccine intentions during a hypothetical pandemic. In an online randomised study with 720 participants, we assessed whether user-generated or algorithmically generated corrections influenced perceived social norms measured as beliefs about other's vaccination intentions (empirical expectations about vaccination), perception about the social appropriateness of vaccine refusal (normative expectations), and beliefs about others' perceptions of vaccine safety (second-order normative beliefs), and own vaccine intentions. User-generated corrections significantly increased the perceptions that refusing vaccination is socially very inappropriate and increased the perception that consensus is in support of vaccine safety. Algorithmic corrections did not influence social norm perceptions. Interestingly, neither social nor algorithmic corrections significantly altered empirical expectations about others' vaccination intentions. Both corrections also helped maintain participants' high initial vaccine intentions with algorithmic correction having stronger effects, in contrast to a significant decline in intentions observed in the control group exposed to misinformation without corrections. Algorithmic corrections from credible health agencies were effective in sustaining vaccine intentions, while user-generated corrections were more influential in improving perceptions of social norms. The findings suggests that different correction types on social media may influence distinct determinants of vaccination behaviour during a pandemic: user-generated corrections reshape perceived social norms of vaccination, while algorithmic corrections, citing credible sources, may better sustain high personal vaccine intentions.
引用
- Shanker A, Vlaev I. The social influence of the corrections of vaccine misinformation on social media. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40300437. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127177
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。