「宁愿尝试而死」:纳米比亚农村牧民的疫苗认知与COVID-19经历
研究于2024年7月至8月在纳米比亚北部库内内地区辛巴族和赫雷罗族牧民中开展混合性别焦点小组,探讨健康文化模型、疫苗规范及COVID-19信念与经历。结果显示儿童疫苗免疫是常态且由女性主导决策,成人接种多属个人决定,对COVID-19疫苗安全性的担忧常见但通常被对疾病的恐惧所压倒。
要点
- 儿童疫苗免疫是常态且被期待,女性是主要决策者,反映母系 kinship 偏向。
- 成人接种决策 largely 个人化,地方领袖在与公共卫生外展对接中有一定影响。
- 对COVID-19疫苗安全性的担忧常见,但多数人报告因更恐惧疾病而仍接种疫苗。
核心结论
- 研究强调需超越知识、态度、实践框架,纳入地方解释模型和文化历史经历来理解疫苗决策,在医疗不信任常见且地方疾病解释模型驱动决策的传统、农村和边缘化人群中尤为重要。
研究设计与样本
- 2024年7月至8月在纳米比亚北部库内内地区农村和城郊梯度社区开展混合性别焦点小组,讨论提示旨在引出疫苗接种信念、规范和经历以及近期COVID-19经历。
主要发现
- 焦点小组结果显示,区分疫苗接种与其他类型注射存在大量混淆。
- 儿童疫苗免疫是常态且被期待,女性是主要决策者,反映辛巴族和赫雷罗族亲属关系的母系偏向。
- 成人方面,地方领袖在与公共卫生外展对接中有一定影响,但接种决定 largely 是个人决定。
- 对COVID-19的信念通过既存疾病文化模型解读,对COVID-19起源的信念反映对国际行为体的不信任。
- 对COVID-19疫苗的恐惧常见,尤其担心疫苗安全性;但对疾病的恐惧通常压倒对疫苗的恐惧,多数人报告尽管有担忧仍接种了疫苗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Substantial research indicates that local explanatory models of disease shape heath behaviors. However, less is known regarding how cultural models of disease influence interpretations of vaccines. Vaccination decisions are based around a plethora of social and cultural factors, including beliefs about disease, cultural-historical experiences with healthcare, and recent vaccination experiences. To understand how local interpretations of vaccination influence vaccination-decision making, we explore cultural models of health, vaccine norms, and COVID-19 beliefs and experiences in Himba and Herero pastoralists of the Kunene region of northern Namibia. Mixed sex focus groups were conducted in July and August of 2024 in communities across a rural and peri-urban gradient. Discussion prompts were designed to elicit dialogue on vaccination beliefs, norms, and experiences, as well as their recent experience with COVID-19. Results from these focus groups indicate that there was substantial confusion differentiating vaccinations from other types of injections. For childhood vaccines, immunization is normative and expected. Women were the primary decision-makers for childhood immunization, reflecting the matrilineal bias of Himba and Herero kinship. For adults, while local leaders had some influence interfacing with public health outreach, the decision to get vaccinated was largely a personal one. Beliefs about COVID-19 were interpreted through pre-existing cultural models of illness, and beliefs about the origins of COVID-19 reflected mistrust in international actors. Fears about COVID-19 vaccines were common, particularly concerns about vaccine safety. However, fears of the illness typically overrode fears of the vaccine, and most report receiving the vaccine despite these worries. These results highlight the importance of extending research beyond a knowledge, attitude, practice framework to incorporate local explanatory models and cultural-historical experiences in understanding vaccine-decision making. These features are particularly important in more traditional, rural, and marginalized populations where medical mistrust is common and local explanatory models of disease drive healthcare decision-making.
引用
- Prall S, Lopes A. "Better to die trying": Vaccine perceptions and COVID-19 experiences in rural Namibian pastoralists. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40199171. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.127061
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。