公民对稀缺救命资源分配偏好的社会人口学差异:基于比利时COVID-19疫苗分配的案例研究
研究对比利时2060名代表样本调查八种疫苗优先策略的排序,将策略聚类为五类并分析社会人口学特征的影响。脆弱策略(慢性病患者和老年人)最常被首选(N=1815),市场策略最少(N=116)。女性、老年人或退休者、法兰德斯居民、对疫苗接种持积极态度或高接种意愿者、偏好政府或科学家决定优先顺序者更倾向指定优先策略;年轻受访者、瓦隆居民和既往感染者更倾向风险无关策略。
要点
- 脆弱策略(慢性病患者和老年人)最常被首选(N=1815),市场策略最少(N=116)。
- 女性、老年人或退休者等群体更可能偏好指定优先策略。
- 年轻受访者、瓦隆居民和既往感染者更倾向风险无关策略。
核心结论
- 研究支持分阶段首先为脆弱人群接种疫苗的做法,验证了已实施分配方法的适当性。
- 不同亚组偏好差异显著,人群对何为公平的稀缺救命资源分配政策存在分歧。
研究设计与样本
- 对比利时2060名代表样本进行八种优先策略排序调查,将策略聚类为五类,估计社会人口学特征对偏好的潜在影响。
主要发现
- 脆弱策略(慢性病患者和老年人)最常被首选(N=1815),市场策略(先到者或付费最多者)最少被选(N=116)。
- 女性、老年人或退休者、法兰德斯居民、对疫苗接种持积极态度或高接种意愿者、偏好政府或科学家决定优先顺序者更可能偏好指定优先策略(脆弱策略、工作者策略或传播者策略)。
- 年轻受访者、瓦隆居民和既往感染COVID-19者更倾向风险无关优先策略(抽签或市场策略)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为研究结果支持分阶段首先为脆弱人群接种疫苗的做法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The COVID-19 pandemic, particularly the period when safe and protective vaccines became available, presented an excellent opportunity to investigate public preferences regarding how to ration a scarce, life-saving resource. It is important to understand which distributive strategies are preferred but, as this is an inherently normative matter, also to which extent different socio-demographic groups hold different opinions. This study assesses the impact of socio-demographic characteristics on preferences for vaccine prioritization during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic at the moment when vaccines were not available yet. A representative sample of 2060 Belgians were asked to rank eight prioritization strategies. Based on the rankings, we clustered the eight strategies into five overarching groups. Then, we estimated the potential impact of respondents' socio-demographic characteristics on their preferences towards these five strategies. The ranking exercise shows that the vulnerability strategy (i.e. chronically ill and elderly) is preferred most often (N = 1815) and the market strategy (i.e. individuals who come first or pay the most) by the fewest respondents (N = 116). Preferences for vaccine distribution vary among population subgroups. Women, older or retired individuals, residents of Flanders, those with a positive attitude towards vaccination efforts and/or high vaccination willingness, and those who prefer the government or scientists to decide upon prioritization were more likely to prefer a designated priority strategy (i.e. vulnerability strategy, workers strategy or spreaders). Furthermore, younger respondents, residents of Wallonia, and those previously infected by COVID-19 tended to favour a risk-independent prioritization strategy (i.e. lottery or market strategy) more than others. This study validates the appropriateness of the implemented rationing approaches, by supporting a phased approach in which first vulnerables were vaccinated. However, it also demonstrates that different subgroups had substantially different preferences and the population was in disagreement about what constitutes a fair rationing policy for a scarce, potentially lifesaving resource.
引用
- Raskin N, Hiligsmann M, Luyten J, et al. Socio-demographic differences in citizen' preferences for distributing a scarce, lifesaving resource: A case study using COVID-19 vaccine distribution in Belgium. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40112555. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126997
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。