加拿大面向5-11岁儿童照护者的COVID-19疫苗接种在线资源综述
本研究评估了截至2022年4月22日加拿大面向5-11岁儿童照护者的COVID-19疫苗在线资源质量,共分析43个主要网页集群和141个次级网页。多数网页在可理解性上得分较高,但在可操作性、可读性和内容方面仍需改进。
要点
- 43个主要网页集群中仅5个(11.6%)达到美国6年级及以下阅读水平。
- 42/43(97.7%)主要集群含可打印材料可理解(PEMAT-P>70%),仅7/43(16.3%)被认为可操作。
- 不同机构类型间质量无差异,仅可操作性有差异(p=0.016)。
核心结论
- 多数加拿大COVID-19疫苗网页在可理解性上得分高,但在可操作性、可读性和内容方面需改进。
研究设计与样本
- 综述加拿大面向公众的网站,来源包括学术儿科医院、政府、专业组织和公共卫生机构,截至2022年4月22日。
- 纳入标准为针对5-11岁儿童照护者的英语/法语资源,形式包括网页、FAQ、海报/信息图和/或视频。
- 共筛选1046个网站,分析43个主要网页集群和141个次级网页。
- 使用JAMA Benchmark、Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level和PEMAT-P/A工具分别评估可靠性、可读性和可理解性/可操作性。
- 使用内容清单评估关键疫苗主题(如有效性和安全性),描述性统计包括Fisher精确检验和ANOVA检验。
主要发现
- 43个主要网页集群中,政府20个(46.5%)、学术儿科医院9个(20.9%)、专业组织7个(16.3%)、公共卫生机构7个(16.3%)。
- JAMA Benchmark平均得分为3.47±0.55(满分43)。
- 43个集群中仅5个(11.6%)得分达到或低于美国6年级教育水平。
- 42/43(97.7%)含可打印材料的主要集群可理解(PEMAT-P>70%),仅7/43(16.3%)被认为可操作。
- 43个主要集群的平均内容得分为12.65±3.60(满分20)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Vaccination is one of the most searched health topics online, yet the quality of resources varies considerably. This study evaluated the quality of Canadian COVID-19 vaccines online resources for caregivers of 5-11-year-old children. METHODS: We reviewed Canadian public-facing websites from academic pediatric hospitals, governments, professional organizations, and public health authorities until April 22, 2022. Inclusion criteria included English/French resources targeting caregivers of 5-11-year-olds, presented as webpages, FAQs, posters/infographics, and/or videos. Reliability, readability, and understandability/actionability were appraised using the JAMA Benchmark, Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level, and Patient Education Material Assessment Tool for Printable/Audiovisual materials, respectively. We used a content checklist to assess key vaccine topics (e.g., effectiveness and safety). Descriptive statistics included Fisher's exact and ANOVA tests. RESULTS: Of 1046 websites screened, 43 primary webpage clusters and 141 secondary webpages were analyzed. Twenty (46.5 %), 9 (20.9 %), 7 (16.3 %), and 7 (16.3 %) primary webpage clusters belonged to government, academic pediatric hospitals, professional organizations, and public health authorities, respectively. The mean JAMA Benchmark score was 3.47 ± 0.55 (out of 43). Of 43 clusters, only five (11.6 %) scored at or below a US 6th-grade education level. While 42/43 (97.7 %) primary clusters including printable materials were understandable (PEMAT-P > 70 %), only 7/43 (16.3 %) were considered actionable. The mean content score was 12.65 ± 3.60 (out of 20) among the 43 primary clusters. No differences in quality were seen across organization types, except for actionability (p = 0.016). CONCLUSIONS: Although most Canadian webpages on COVID-19 vaccines received high scores in understandability, areas requiring improvement in actionability, readability, and content were identified.
引用
- Di Chiara C, Karimi-Shahrbabak E, Peresin J, et al. A review of Canadian online resources providing information on COVID-19 vaccination for caregivers of children aged 5-11 years. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40068568. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126990
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。