住院儿童青少年家长报告与记录COVID-19疫苗接种状态的一致性:对疫苗有效性估计的启示,2021年5月至2023年10月
基于2021年5月至2023年10月疫苗有效性监测网络数据,比较25个州35家医院5-18岁住院患者家长报告与记录的COVID-19疫苗剂次。3262例中一致性88%(kappa=0.77),不一致多因家长高报;两种来源估计的两剂疫苗有效性相似(记录来源58% vs 家长报告60%)。
要点
- 家长报告与记录COVID-19疫苗接种剂量一致性为88%(kappa=0.77)。
- 不一致主要因家长高报剂量(346/390对)。
- 记录来源估计两剂疫苗有效性58%,家长报告为60%。
核心结论
- 家长报告的COVID-19疫苗接种史与记录来源高度一致,尤其未接种者;尽管存在家长高报导致的不一致,两种来源的疫苗有效性估计相似。
研究设计与样本
- 利用2021年5月至2023年10月疫苗有效性监测网络数据,比较25个州35家医院5-18岁住院患者的家长报告与记录COVID-19疫苗剂量,总体及按病例/对照状态分析。
主要发现
- 3262例患者中,家长报告与记录COVID-19疫苗剂量一致性为88%(kappa=0.77)。
- 390对不一致中有346对因家长高报剂量;记录为未接种者中90%被家长报告为未接种(特异性=90%),家长报告未接种者中99%无记录接种(NPV=99%)。
- 不一致比例随入院至访谈间隔缩短而降低,地区差异从中西部8%到西部16%;有与无SARS-CoV-2感染患者的不一致比例相似(11% vs 13%)。
- 末次疫苗剂量至入院中位天数为167天(IQR:86-288)。
- 两剂疫苗(99%为原始配方)对抗COVID-19相关住院的有效性:记录来源58%,家长报告60%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: During the U.S. COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE), healthcare providers were required to report all administered COVID-19 vaccines in Immunization Information Systems (IIS), a key data source for vaccine effectiveness (VE) evaluations. Expiration of the PHE and commercialization of COVID-19 vaccines raised concerns about IIS data completeness. Parental report is an alternative source of vaccination data but might be inaccurate. METHODS: Using VE surveillance network data during May 2021-October 2023, we compared parent-reported and documented COVID-19 vaccine doses for patients aged 5-18 years admitted to 35 hospitals in 25 states, overall and by case/control status. We calculated percent agreement, kappa, sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive value (NPV) of parental report. We compared proportions of patients with discordant vaccination history by demographics and incident SARS-CoV-2 infection status. We estimated VE separately using parental report and independently documented sources. RESULTS: Among 3262 patients, agreement between parent-reported and documented COVID-19 vaccination doses was 88 % (kappa = 0.77). Most discordant pairs (346/390) were because of parental over-reporting of doses. Among patients documented as unvaccinated, most (specificity = 90 %) were reported as such by parents; nearly all reported as unvaccinated by parents had no documented vaccination (NPV = 99 %). Discordance decreased with shorter admission-to-interview intervals and varied regionally from 8 % in the Midwest to 16 % in the West. Proportions of discordant reports were similar between patients with and without SARS-CoV-2 infection (11 % vs 13 %). Median days from last vaccine dose to hospital admission was 167 (IQR: 86-288). VE of two doses (99 % original formula) against COVID-19-related hospitalization was 58 % using documented sources and 60 % using parental report. CONCLUSIONS: Parental report of COVID-19 vaccination agreed strongly with documented sources, especially among unvaccinated patients. Despite discrepancies from parental overreporting, VE estimates from both sources were similar. As reliance on parental report increases, reducing admission-to-interview time is important for accurate vaccination history.
引用
- Hamid S, Simeone RM, Newhams MM, et al. Concordance between parent-reported and documented COVID-19 vaccination status among hospitalized children and adolescents: Implications for vaccine effectiveness estimates, May 2021-October 2023. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40117941. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126891
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。