文献速递免疫规划妇幼与学校卫生卫生政策与健康促进

现实主义综述:低至中高收入国家将HPV疫苗接种与其他青少年健康服务整合的经验

Realist review of low- to upper-middle-income country experiences on integration of HPV vaccination with other adolescent health services.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2025-02-06

该现实主义综述综合低至中高收入国家将HPV疫苗接种与其他青少年健康服务整合的已发表经验,检索1961篇同行评议文章和16篇灰色文献,最终纳入8篇文章、覆盖6个国家经验,迭代形成变革理论框架。综述指出整合可能关联覆盖、可持续性和公平递送等有利项目结局,但在服务未充分覆盖人群(如校外青少年和受HIV影响者)方面证据存在明显空白,迭代变革理论新增9个因素、弃用4个因素。

要点

  • 纳入8篇文章、覆盖6个国家经验,迭代形成整合HPV疫苗与青少年健康服务的变革理论。
  • 整合可能关联覆盖、可持续性和公平递送等有利项目结局,但证据尚未充分整合以指导政策。
  • 证据在满足校外青少年和受HIV影响者等未充分覆盖人群独特需求方面存在明显空白。

核心结论

  • 据作者所知,本现实主义综述是首个整合关于如何用整合方法有效递送HPV疫苗和其他青少年健康服务的操作证据的综述。
  • 迭代的变革理论为未来实施研究提供框架,以确保将观察到的效果归因于整合方法具有合理性,并为青少年免疫政策和项目决策提供信息。

研究设计与样本

  • 现实主义综合综述,检索三个大型学术同行评议数据库、灰色文献及关键参考文献的滚雪球引文,并邀请专家作为综述专员参与变革理论(TOC)的制定与迭代。
  • 从1961篇同行评议文章和16篇灰色文献文章中筛选出8篇符合纳入标准的文章,提供来自6个国家经验的数据以开发迭代TOC。

主要发现

  • TOC迭代产生9个新因素和4个弃用因素。
  • 显著的新因素包括多部门合作机制,该机制与使用大量其他机制相关联,包括整合费用分担、供应链分发和项目监测。
  • 证据在整合方法如何满足校外青少年和受HIV影响者等未充分覆盖人群的独特需求方面存在明显空白。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为迭代TOC提供框架以指导未来实施研究,确保将观察到的效果归因于整合方法具有合理性。
  • 作者认为迭代TOC可为青少年免疫政策和项目决策提供信息。

局限性

  • 证据在整合方法如何满足校外青少年和受HIV影响者等未充分覆盖人群的独特需求方面存在明显空白。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Integration of HPV vaccination with other adolescent health services may be associated with favorable programme outcomes including coverage, sustainability, and equitable delivery. Interest in such integrated approaches is building. However, the empirical evidence on how an integrated approach might be used to effectively deliver HPV vaccines and other adolescent health services has not been consolidated in a manner sufficient to inform policy and programmes. METHODS: We conducted a realist synthesis review of published experiences from low- to upper-middle-income countries. Experts were invited as review commissioners, informing development and iteration of a programme theory of change (TOC). Our search strategy queried three large academic peer-review databases, grey literature, and a "snowball" of citations from key reference articles. We extracted learnings from specific real-world country experiences, exploring theoretical constructs describing the context in which an integration mechanism may deliver intended outcomes. RESULTS: Of 1961 peer-reviewed articles and 16 grey literature articles identified, 8 articles met inclusion criteria, providing data from 6 country experiences to develop an iterated TOC. There were notable gaps in evidence regarding how an integrated approach might meet unique needs of underserved populations, including out of school youth and those affected by HIV. TOC iterations yielded 9 new factors and 4 discarded factors. Notable new factors included a multisectoral cooperation mechanism, linked to the use of a large number of other mechanisms, including integration of cost-sharing, supply chain distribution, and programme monitoring. CONCLUSION: This realist synthesis is to our knowledge the first review consolidating operational evidence on how an integrated approach might be used to effectively deliver HPV vaccines and other adolescent health services. Our iterated TOC provides a framework to guide future implementation research, to ensure attribution of observed effects to an integrated approach is merited - and to inform decision-making in adolescent immunization policy and programmes.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jennings MC, Nabia S, Morgan C, et al. Realist review of low- to upper-middle-income country experiences on integration of HPV vaccination with other adolescent health services. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 39919446. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126833

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。