文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进传染病防控与疫情报告

19世纪早期意大利北部首次天花疫苗接种运动的历史分析:对当代流行病预防与控制的组织与沟通启示

Historical analysis of the first smallpox vaccination campaigns in early 19-century northern Italy: organisation and communication insights for contemporary epidemics' prevention and control.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2025-01-30

该研究通过分析帕维亚历史市民档案馆、帕维亚国家档案馆和米兰国家档案馆的一手资料,考察了19世纪早期意大利北部首次天花疫苗接种运动及路易吉·萨科的开创性工作。研究聚焦1816—1828年伦巴第地区,发现1821年组织改革使帕维亚接种数量翻倍并在随后年份稳定在较高水平,萨科倡导的学术与宗教合作沟通策略显示有效。作者从地方行政机构作用、强制接种与自主执行的平衡、可信沟通策略三方面提出现代启示。

要点

  • 1821年组织改革使帕维亚接种数量翻倍,并在后续年份稳定在较高水平。
  • 萨科推动的学术与宗教合作沟通策略被证明有效。
  • 流行病学数据显示1822年接种率初始激增,随后年份呈下降趋势,受后勤和数据记录限制影响。

核心结论

  • 研究强调三个与当代公共卫生范式相关的显著维度:地方行政机构作为有效服务提供者、免疫登记保存者和社会安全网的重要功能;强制疫苗接种政策与自主执行之间的平衡作为促进公众依从的务实框架;可信沟通策略在应对疫苗犹豫中的不可否认的重要性。

研究设计与样本

  • 历史研究,审查帕维亚历史市民档案馆、帕维亚国家档案馆和米兰国家档案馆的一手资料,使用特定时期关键词检索和专家咨询,广泛回顾信件、接种名单和学术著作,包括路易吉·萨科的《接种论》。
  • 流行病学调查聚焦1816—1828年伦巴第19世纪公共卫生格局的关键时期。

主要发现

  • 1821年实施的组织改革使帕维亚接种数量翻倍,并在随后年份稳定在较高水平。
  • 尽管有所改善,流行病学数据和接种者报酬方面仍存在不一致。
  • 萨科开创的沟通策略(包括学术和宗教合作)显示有效。
  • 流行病学数据显示1822年接种率初始激增,随后年份呈下降趋势,显著受后勤和数据记录限制影响。

局限性

  • 流行病学数据存在不一致。
  • 接种者报酬方面存在不一致。
  • 后勤和数据记录限制对流行病学数据趋势产生显著影响。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In the annals of public health, smallpox is a watershed, being the first disease eradicated by vaccination. Drawing parallels to contemporary pandemic control measures, we examined the first smallpox vaccination campaigns in early 19th-century northern Italy and the seminal work of Luigi Sacco. Our study delves into this under-explored historical landscape to elucidate lessons that resonate with modern public health dilemmas. METHODS: We scrutinised primary sources from the Historical Civic Archive of Pavia, the State Archive of Pavia, and the State Archive of Milan. These archives provided exhaustive data on administrative decrees, local epidemiology, and university-health authority collaborations. Using period-specific keyword searches and expert consultations, we extensively reviewed correspondence, vaccination lists, and academic writings, including Luigi Sacco's seminal Trattato di vaccinazione. The epidemiological investigation focused on the pivotal period of 1816-1828 in Lombardy's 19th-century public health landscape. RESULTS: Organisational reforms enacted in 1821 succeeded in doubling the number of vaccinations administered in Pavia, stabilising at elevated rates in subsequent years. Despite improvements, incongruities in epidemiological data and vaccinator remuneration persisted. Communication strategies pioneered by Sacco, encompassing academic and religious collaborations, demonstrated their efficacy. Epidemiological data revealed an initial surge in vaccination uptake in 1822, with a declining trend in the following years, notably impacted by logistical and data recording limitations. CONCLUSION: Our research underscores three salient dimensions pertinent to contemporary public health paradigms: first, the vital function of local administrative bodies as efficacious service providers, immunisation register keepers, and social safety nets; second, the equilibrium between mandatory vaccination policies and discretionary enforcement as a pragmatic framework for public compliance; lastly, the irrefutable importance of credible communication strategies in fighting vaccine hesitancy. These insights are not merely historical curiosities but cardinal principles for effectively managing modern epidemics and infectious disease threats.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vigezzi GP, Vecchio R, Barbati C, et al. Historical analysis of the first smallpox vaccination campaigns in early 19-century northern Italy: organisation and communication insights for contemporary epidemics' prevention and control. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 39889535. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126764

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。