全球应急疫苗储备的动态:系统分析及其在霍乱中的应用
本研究采用定性研究设计,结合文献与专家半结构化访谈,运用系统分析和定性因果回路图,探讨全球应急疫苗储备在实现公共卫生目标中的作用及驱动其绩效的卫生系统结构,并以霍乱为例。研究发现,尽管口服霍乱疫苗储备扩大,但2021年以来供应短缺加剧,部分原因在于疫情激增和疫苗有效性证据积累导致需求增加,供应约束导致反应性接种运动订单延迟和预防性使用暂停。结论指出,随着疾病流行病学、疫苗接种策略、接种率和供应市场异步演变,需要能更好整合供需动态的决策支持工具,从而拓展传统上狭窄的模型边界。
要点
- 尽管扩大口服霍乱疫苗储备,2021年以来供应短缺加剧,部分因疫情激增和疫苗有效性证据积累致需求增加。
- 供应约束导致反应性接种运动订单延迟和预防性使用暂停,使人群脆弱。
- 需决策支持工具更好整合供需动态,拓展传统狭窄模型边界。
核心结论
- 随着疾病流行病学、疫苗接种策略、接种率和供应市场异步演变,需要能更好整合供需动态的决策支持工具,从而拓展传统上狭窄的模型边界。
研究设计与样本
- 采用定性研究设计,结合文献见解和与从事储备相关活动的专家的半结构化访谈。
- 运用定性因果回路图进行系统分析,包括识别系统要素、要素间重要关系及由此产生的反馈回路。
主要发现
- 尽管扩大口服霍乱疫苗储备,2021年以来供应短缺加剧,部分可由疫情激增和疫苗有效性证据积累导致需求增加来解释。
- 供应约束导致反应性接种运动疫苗订单履行延迟和预防性使用暂停,使人群脆弱。
- 尽管持续努力扩大生产,设计有效的风险分担政策以吸引制造商仍面临挑战,因需求预测不确定和订单不稳定。
- 文献中很少联合考虑支撑疾病出现和传播的时间依赖且复杂的环境、社会、人口和结构驱动因素,难以预测储备相对于其他防范策略的变化作用和使用。
- 随着时间推移,全球应急疫苗储备可支持从反应性策略向主动性策略过渡,帮助实现向疾病消除演变的公共卫生目标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The frequency and magnitude of infectious disease outbreaks are expected to rise. Although emergency vaccine stockpiles have emerged as a strategy to hedge against sporadic demand and accelerate response efforts, their long-term management is complex. OBJECTIVE: This study investigates the role of global emergency vaccine stockpiles in achieving public health goals over time and underlying health system structures that drive their performance, with an application to cholera. METHODS: A qualitative study design was used, combining insights from literature and semi-structured interviews with experts engaged in stockpile-related activities. A systems analysis, using qualitative causal loop diagrams, helps explain global stockpile behavior and discuss leverage points for change. It includes identifying system elements, important relationship between them, and resulting feedback loops. FINDINGS: Despite expanding the stockpile for oral cholera vaccines, growing supply shortages since 2021 can partly be explained by increased demand due to a surge in outbreaks and the accumulation of evidence on vaccine effectiveness. These supply constraints have led to delays fulfilling vaccine orders for reactive campaigns and a pause on preventive use, leaving populations vulnerable. Despite ongoing efforts to scale-up production, a continued challenge is designing effective risk-sharing policies to attract manufacturers given uncertainty in demand forecasts and erratic orders. In literature, the time-dependent and complex environmental, social, demographic, and structural drivers that underpin the emergence and spread of disease are rarely jointly considered, making it difficult to anticipate the changing role and use of stockpiles relative to other preparedness strategies. Over time, global emergency vaccine stockpiles can support the transition from reactive to proactive strategies, helping achieve evolving public health goals towards disease elimination. CONCLUSIONS: As disease epidemiology, vaccination strategies, uptake, and supply markets evolve asynchronously, there is a need for decision-support tools that better integrate supply and demand dynamics, hence expanding traditionally narrow model boundaries.
引用
- Guttieres D, Van Riet C, Vandaele N, et al. Dynamics of global emergency vaccine stockpiles: A systems analysis and application to cholera. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 40014984. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126889
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。