文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

一项量化瑞典COVID-19疫苗接种影响的反事实分析

A counterfactual analysis quantifying the COVID-19 vaccination impact in Sweden.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2025-02-20

本研究以瑞典为案例,使用年龄别报告发病率和疫苗接种率、疫苗效力、年龄别接触模式及文献中的漏报数据,拟合带时变社区接触率的贝叶斯SEIR模型,通过反事实分析估计2021年疫苗接种避免的死亡数。结果显示,若未接种疫苗,2021年初秋将出现严重疫情暴发,约产生37,100例死亡;疫苗接种项目估计挽救了约31,600条生命,其中直接挽救5,170人,间接挽救26,400人。

要点

  • 反事实分析估计,若未接种疫苗,2021年初秋将出现严重疫情暴发,约37,100例死亡。
  • 疫苗接种项目估计挽救约31,600条生命,其中直接挽救5,170人,间接挽救26,400人。
  • 间接挽救主要归因于大幅减少若未接种且社区接触率不变时本应出现的严重疫情暴发。

核心结论

  • 数学模型分析显示,瑞典2021年COVID-19疫苗接种估计挽救了约31,600条生命,其中直接挽救5,170人,间接挽救26,400人。
  • 反事实分析表明,若未接种疫苗且社区接触率不变,2021年初秋将出现严重疫情暴发,约产生37,100例死亡。
  • 该建模方法可应用于其他国家,反事实分析有助于了解无疫苗接种情况下的替代疫情轨迹。

研究设计与样本

  • 使用瑞典年龄别报告发病率和疫苗接种率、疫苗效力、年龄别接触模式及文献中的漏报数据,拟合带时变社区接触率的贝叶斯SEIR模型。
  • 事实分析中,文献年龄别病死率按比例调整以拟合观察到的死亡数,得到5,510(95% PI:5,370-5,650),与观察数5,430匹配。
  • 将估计的时变社区接触率用于人口未接种疫苗的反事实分析,并进行敏感性分析以识别影响结论的参数。

主要发现

  • 反事实分析显示2021年初秋出现严重疫情暴发,约37,100(36,700-37,500)例死亡。
  • 疫苗接种项目估计挽救约31,600(31,300-32,000)条生命,其中直接挽救5,170人,间接挽救26,400人。
  • 间接挽救主要归因于大幅减少若未接种且社区接触率不变时本应于2021年初秋出现的严重疫情暴发。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Vaccination was the single most effective measure in mitigating the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Our study aims to quantify the impact of vaccination programmes during the initial year of vaccination (2021) by estimating the number of case fatalities avoided, using Sweden as a case study. METHODS: Using Swedish data on age-specific reported incidence and vaccination uptake, along with vaccine efficacies, age-specific contact patterns and under-reporting from the literature, we fit a Bayesian SEIR epidemic model with time-varying community contact rate for COVID-19 incidence. Age-specific fatality rates from the literature are adjusted proportionally to fit the observed number of case fatalities in the factual analysis, resulting in 5,510 (95% PI: 5,370-5,650) matching the observed number 5,430. The estimated time-varying community contact rate is then used in a counterfactual analysis where the population is unvaccinated, leading to more infections and fatalities. A sensitivity analysis is performed to identify which parameters influence our conclusions. FINDINGS: The counterfactual analysis result in a severe epidemic outbreak during the early autumn of 2021, resulting in about 37,100 (36,700-37,500) number of case fatalities. Consequently, the number of lives saved by the vaccination programme is estimated to be about 31,600 (31,300-32,000), out of which 5,170 are directly saved and 26,400 are indirectly saved, mainly by drastically reducing the severe outbreak in the early autumn of 2021, which would have occurred without vaccination and unchanged community contact rate. INTERPRETATION: Our mathematical model is used to analyse the impact of COVID-19 vaccination on lives saved in Sweden during 2021, but the same methodology can be applied to other countries. The counterfactual analysis offers insights into an alternative trajectory of the pandemic without vaccination. The results show the direct impact of vaccination on reducing deaths for infected individuals and shed light on the indirect effects of reduced transmission dynamics.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Bergström F, Günther F, Britton T, et al. A counterfactual analysis quantifying the COVID-19 vaccination impact in Sweden. Vaccine. 2025. PMID: 39983319. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2025.126870

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。