探索使用虚构故事在社交媒体上进行健康教育以分享人乳头瘤病毒疫苗信息与情绪的伦理问题:一项与跨学科健康专家的横断面研究
该横断面调查于2021年10月至12月对41名健康传播、癌症预防、社交媒体和公共卫生伦理领域的研究者进行问卷,评估使用虚构故事在社交媒体分享HPV疫苗信息与情绪的伦理关切。受访者平均认为获益大于风险,认为强调疫苗犹豫、积极情绪和健康公平的片段潜在获益最大,而强调疫苗信心和怀疑的片段潜在风险最大。受访者报告的伦理关切包括说服(15%)、欺骗(9%)和操纵(8%),定性数据强调透明和信任的重要性。
要点
- 受访者平均认为使用社交媒体进行健康教育和使用连接片段的故事进行疫苗沟通的获益大于风险。
- 强调疫苗犹豫、积极情绪和健康公平的片段被认为潜在获益最大,强调疫苗信心和怀疑的片段潜在风险最大。
- 伦理关切中说服最常见(15%),其次为欺骗(9%)和操纵(8%),透明和信任被强调以避免伦理违规和负面结果。
核心结论
- 使用虚构故事在社交媒体分享健康信息时存在伦理关切,尤其新在线技术使区分事实与虚构更加困难。
- 必须为研究者制定实用且可操作的建议,界定一系列伦理责任。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面调查,于2021年10月至12月对健康传播、癌症预防、社交媒体和公共卫生伦理领域的研究者进行。
- 受访者(n=41)阅读一个由七个相连片段组成的关于HPV疫苗的虚构故事,并对每个片段的潜在获益、风险及伦理关切进行评分。
主要发现
- 受访者(n=41)平均认为使用社交媒体进行健康教育总体上获益大于风险。
- 受访者(n=41)平均认为使用连接片段的故事进行疫苗沟通获益大于风险。
- 强调疫苗犹豫、积极情绪和健康公平的片段被认为潜在获益最大,强调疫苗信心和怀疑的片段被认为潜在风险最大。
- 伦理关切中说服最常见(15%的受访者),其次为欺骗(9%)和操纵(8%)。
- 定性数据强调透明和信任对避免伦理违规和负面结果的重要性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
UNLABELLED: Social media is used to promote the HPV vaccine through various strategies, including the use of stories and narratives. Understanding the ethical concerns related to the use of social media in this capacity are important. The purpose of this study is to identify ethical concerns of using fictional stories to share information and emotions about the HPV vaccine on social media, ultimately to influence parents on their decision to vaccinate their child. METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional survey with researchers in the fields of health communication, cancer prevention, social media, and public health ethics from October to December 2021. Respondents were presented with a fictional story that consisted of seven connected vignettes about the HPV vaccine. For each vignette, respondents were asked to rate the potential benefits and risk, as well as the potential for ethical concerns of using the fictional narrative style to share information about the HPV vaccine. Descriptive statistics summarized responses, and qualitative data were analyzed thematically. RESULTS: On average, respondents (n = 41) perceived more benefits than risks when it comes to 1) using social media for health education generally and 2) using a story with connected vignettes for vaccine communication. The vignettes prioritizing vaccine hesitancy, positive emotion, and health equity were seen as having the most potential benefit, while the vignettes highlighting vaccine confidence and skepticism were seen as having the most potential risk. Overall, respondents felt there were several ethical concerns of note - persuasion was the most common (15 % of respondents) followed by deception (9 %) and manipulation (8 %). Qualitative data highlighted the importance of transparency and trust to avoid ethical violations and negative outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Ethical concerns exist when using fictional stories to share health information on social media, particularly as new online technologies make it harder to tell fact from fiction. Practical and actionable recommendations for researchers must be developed, defining a range of ethical responsibilities.
引用
- Massey PM, Murray RM, Kostizak K, et al. Exploring the ethics of using fictional stories for health education on social media to share information and emotions about the HPV vaccine: A cross-sectional study with interdisciplinary health experts. Vaccine. 2024. PMID: 39665977. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2024.126575
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。