拷问式忏悔?潜在错误的统计推断可能支撑对COVID-19和HPV疫苗再分析中有害性的误导性声明
本文检视了针对COVID-19和HPV疫苗原始试验数据的再分析报告,发现错误的统计假设和不合理推断可能影响了这些再分析的结论,并识别出易导致虚假结果的分析选择。文章还讨论了未经预注册的事后检验、数据 dredging 及如何防范此类问题。
要点
- 再分析中错误的统计假设和不合理推断可能影响结论。
- 未经预注册的事后分析可能导致数据 dredging 和虚假关联。
- 需防范疫苗科学中数据拷问式分析。
核心结论
- 在COVID-19和HPV疫苗的再分析中,错误的统计假设和不合理推断可能影响了结论,并识别出易导致虚假结果的分析选择。
研究设计与样本
- 本文检视了针对COVID-19和HPV疫苗原始试验数据的再分析报告。
主要发现
- 在两种疫苗的案例中,错误的统计假设和不合理推断可能影响了再分析得出的结论。
- 识别出一些分析选择倾向于导致虚假发现。
- 讨论了未经预注册对已知试验数据进行事后检验的更广泛问题,以及这如何可能导致数据 dredging。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The safety and efficacy of vaccination is a subject contentious in the public mind. Despite overwhelming evidence of their benefits to public health, COVID-19 and human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccines have been the focus of intense concerns. While the original phase III trials and post-market phase IV studies have continued to show their benefits and positive safety profile, some authors have attempted to reassess the original trial data, purporting to showing hidden harms for both COVID-19 and HPV vaccines. It is critical to ascertain why such divergent claims could stem from analysis of the same data, and this work accordingly examines these reports. In both cases, we find that erroneous statistical assumptions and unwarranted inferences are likely to have influenced the conclusions drawn, and identifies choices that would tend to result in spurious findings. This work also examines the wider issues with unregistered posthoc examinations on known trial data without preregistration, and how this may result in data-dredging, the torturing of data until it confesses to non-existent relationships, and how we might prevent against this on vaccine science.
引用
- Grimes DR. Tortured confessions? Potentially erroneous statistical inferences may underpin misleading claims of harms in reanalyses of COVID-19 and HPV vaccines. Vaccine. 2024. PMID: 39725574. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2024.126657
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。