短信提醒如何提高新冠疫苗加强针接种率:两项随机对照试验
RCT1显示所有权框架短信(「您的疫苗已为您准备好」)接种率最高(对比无短信:OR=1.28 [99%CI 1.03-1.59]);RCT2显示所有权框架加具体日期、时间、地点的短信接种率最高(对比无短信:OR=2.10 [99%CI 1.85-2.38])。多数短信效果持续较长时间,作者建议公共卫生当局将短信提醒纳入疫苗接种运动策略。
要点
- 所有权框架短信(「您的疫苗已为您准备好」)对比无短信:OR=1.28(99%CI 1.03-1.59),接种率最高。
- 所有权框架加具体日期、时间、地点的短信对比无短信:OR=2.10(99%CI 1.85-2.38),接种率最高。
- 回复将接种者实际接种可能性高于广泛开放时间短信:OR=2.86(99%CI 2.14-3.82)。
核心结论
- 短信提醒能够提高疫苗加强针接种率。
- 在测试的变体中,提供具体日期、时间、地点的所有权框架短信最有效。
- 由于短信未显示明显劣势,作者建议公共卫生当局将这一有效干预纳入疫苗接种运动策略。
主要发现
- RCT1显示所有权框架短信(「您的疫苗已为您准备好」)对比无短信:OR=1.28(99%CI 1.03-1.59),接种率最高。
- RCT2显示所有权框架加具体日期、时间、地点的短信对比无短信:OR=2.10(99%CI 1.85-2.38),接种率最高。
- 多数短信效果持续较长时间,例如「日期、时间、地点」短信对比无短信:第6天OR=2.10(99%CI 1.85-2.38),第50天OR=1.36(99%CI 1.25-1.48)。
- 收到最有效短信并回复将接种者,实际接种可能性高于广泛开放时间短信:OR=2.86(99%CI 2.14-3.82)。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议公共卫生当局将提供具体日期、时间、地点的所有权框架短信纳入疫苗接种运动策略。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccines are effective and affordable health prevention measures to prevent vaccine-preventable diseases, but achieving sufficient vaccine uptake population-wide is challenging. In this work, we assess the impact of various text messages reminders on COVID-19 booster uptake and the extent to which the effect of messages holds over time. Additionally, we analyse whether people's self-reported vaccination intentions (measured in response to message prompts) corresponds to actual vaccine uptake and whether this relationship differs between message variants. METHODS: We performed two large sequential randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in the Netherlands (N = 140.973), with the design of RCT2 building on the findings of RCT1. We 1) analyzed the effect of various text messages on COVID-19 booster uptake; 2) assessed the extent to which these effects hold over time; and 3) tested whether a positive response to message prompts moderates the effect of message variant on vaccine uptake. RESULTS: First, the results of RCT1 demonstrate that text messages with an ownership frame ("your [vaccine] is ready for you") result in highest vaccine uptake (e.g., compared to no text message: OR = 1.28 [99 % CI 1.03-1.59]). RCT2 showed that text messages with an ownership frame and a specific date, time and location result in highest vaccine uptake (e.g., compared to no text message: OR = 2.10 [99 % CI 1.85-2.38]). Second, most message effects hold over a longer period of time (e.g., 'date, time, location' message versus no message: OR = 2.10 [99 % CI 1.85-2.38] on day 6 and OR = 1.36 [99 % CI 1.25-1.48] on day 50). Third, we find that participants who received our most effective text and replied that they will take the vaccine, are more inclined to actually take the vaccine compared to the message with broad opening hours OR = 2.86 [99 % CI 2.14-3.82]. CONCLUSION: Text message reminders are able to increase vaccine uptake. From the tested variations, messages with an ownership frame providing a specific date, time and location are most effective. Because text messages demonstrate no notable disadvantages, we advise Public Health authorities to include this effective intervention in their vaccination campaign strategies.
引用
- Meeldijk A, Vandeberg L, Akkermans R, et al. How text message reminders increase COVID-19 booster vaccine uptake: Two randomized controlled trials. Vaccine. 2024. PMID: 39561628. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2024.126533
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。