理解加拿大COVID-19疫苗犹豫现象
该研究于2021年10月对18名已接种和未接种的加拿大成年人进行焦点小组访谈,探讨其对COVID-19疫苗的认知与接种决策,以及公共卫生政策和健康信息对接种态度与行为的影响。研究发现疫苗犹豫常与信息过剩或难以在矛盾信息中取舍相关,而非科学知识缺乏;自上而下的促接种信息常引发被访谈者视为道德羞辱的抵触。作者认为需要新框架来理解和应对疫苗犹豫。
要点
- COVID-19疫苗犹豫多与信息过剩或难以在矛盾信息中取舍相关,而非科学知识缺乏。
- 自上而下的促接种信息常引发被访谈者视为对未接种者道德羞辱的抵触。
- 作者认为需要新框架来理解和应对疫苗犹豫。
核心结论
- COVID-19疫苗犹豫在某些方面符合已知的影响疫苗态度的因素(如已知医疗提供者的影响),但在其他方面偏离了当前关于一般疫苗犹豫的理论框架。
- 与知识缺乏解释相反,COVID-19疫苗犹豫的表达最常与信息过剩或无法在多个且常常矛盾的信息来源中优先排序相关。
- 自上而下的促接种信息常引发被访谈者视为对未接种者道德羞辱的显著抵触。
- 研究结果表明需要新框架来理解和应对疫苗犹豫。
研究设计与样本
- 对18名已接种和未接种的加拿大成年人进行焦点小组访谈,访谈于2021年10月进行。
主要发现
- COVID-19疫苗犹豫在某些方面符合已知的影响疫苗态度的因素(如已知医疗提供者的影响)。
- COVID-19疫苗犹豫偏离了强调知识缺乏或情感/非理性解释的当前理论框架。
- COVID-19疫苗犹豫的表达最常与信息过剩或无法在多个且常常矛盾的信息来源中优先排序相关。
- 自上而下的促接种信息常引发被访谈者视为对未接种者道德羞辱的显著抵触。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
While Canada has had relatively high vaccination rates against COVID-19, specifically during earlier waves of the pandemic, vaccine hesitancy has continued to serve as a significant barrier to adequate protection against the virus and, more recently, booster vaccine uptake. This paper explores the processes underlying Canadians' perceptions of COVID-19 vaccines and their decisions to take or refuse them, as well as how public policy and health messaging about vaccination has influenced vaccination attitudes and behaviors. Our focus group interviews with 18 vaccinated and unvaccinated adult Canadians conducted during October 2021 reveal that, in some respects, COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy conforms to prior knowledge about some of the factors that affect vaccine attitudes (e.g., the influence of known medical providers) but deviates from current theoretical frameworks regarding general vaccine hesitancy. Specifically, these frameworks emphasize a lack of scientific knowledge and literacy ("knowledge deficit" accounts) or individuals' inability to incorporate rational risk perceptions into initial emotional responses to vaccines ("emotionality/irrationality" accounts). In contrast to the knowledge deficit account, we find that expressions of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy were most frequently associated with an information surplus or inability to prioritize information from multiple and often contradictory sources. Furthermore, top-down pro-vaccination messaging often triggered significant pushback against what participants perceived as moral shaming of the unvaccinated. Our findings demonstrate the necessity for a new framework to understand and address vaccine hesitancy. A better theoretical account of vaccine hesitancy has important implications for future vaccination efforts, specifically within the context of new variants and low booster vaccination rates in Canada.
引用
- Corsten C, Vang ZM, Gold I, et al. Understanding COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy in Canada. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 39492073. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.10.058
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。