运用健康素养原则提升突发卫生事件中不断演变证据的理解:COVID-19疫苗接种风险-获益计算器的优化与评估
研究通过三阶段优化COVID-19风险计算器(CoRiCal):第一阶段健康素养优化与用户测试(n=19)降低文本和图表复杂度;第二阶段实验(n=207)发现不同风险沟通格式改变感知理解,偏好评价性标签,低健康素养者更偏好条形图;第三阶段随机对照试验(n=2005)显示两种动画均较标准政府信息提高知识,概率格式间及健康素养水平间无差异。
要点
- 健康素养优化可降低风险沟通工具的文本与图表复杂度。
- 不同风险沟通格式改变感知理解,评价性标签和条形图各受特定人群偏好。
- 两种动画解释均较标准政府信息提高COVID-19风险知识,概率格式间无差异。
核心结论
- 对复杂流行病学模型的简单解释可提高对COVID-19和疫苗接种的知识,健康素养设计原则和短动画可支持突发卫生事件中的知情决策。
研究设计与样本
- 研究分三阶段:第一阶段健康素养优化与用户测试(n=19);第二阶段实验探索风险沟通格式对感知理解的影响(n=207);第三阶段四臂随机对照试验(n=2005),组1为标准政府信息,组2为基于条形图的标准CoRiCal输出,组3为以「每百万人x例」格式解释条形图的动画,组4为以「x分之一概率」格式解释条形图的动画,主要结局为COVID-19风险知识。
主要发现
- 第一阶段降低了文本和图表的复杂度。
- 第二阶段显示不同风险沟通格式改变感知理解,2项实验均偏好评价性标签,部分迹象表明低健康素养者更偏好条形图。
- 第三阶段显示两种动画均较标准政府信息提高知识,概率格式间无差异,健康素养水平间无差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Risk communication tools based on epidemiological models can help inform decision-making, but must be responsive to health literacy needs to be effective. To facilitate informed choice about risks and benefits of COVID-19 vaccination, an epidemiological model called the COVID-19 Risk Calculator (CoRiCal) tool was developed by a multi-disciplinary team. AIM: This paper demonstrates how to use health literacy principles to improve consumer understanding of COVID-19 and vaccine effects, using a range of methods that could be applied to any health emergency. METHODS: Stage 1: Health literacy optimisation and user testing to reduce improve understandability (n = 19). Stage 2: Experiments to explore the effect of risk communication formats on perceived understanding including probability, graphs, evaluative labels and comparison risks (n = 207). Stage 3: Randomised controlled trial (n = 2005) with 4 arms: 1) standard government information; 2) standard CoRiCal output based on bar graphs; 3) animation explaining bar graphs in "x per million" format; 4) animation explaining bar graphs in "1 in x chance" format. The primary outcome was knowledge about COVID-19 risk. RESULTS: Stage 1 reduced the complexity of the text and graphs. Stage 2 showed that different risk communication formats change perceived understanding, with a preference for evaluative labels across 2 experiments and some indication people with lower health literacy had a greater preference for bar graphs. Stage 3 showed both animations increased knowledge compared to standard government information. There was no difference between the probability formats, or by health literacy level. DISCUSSION: The results showed that simple explanations of complex epidemiological models improve knowledge about COVID-19 and vaccination. This demonstrates how health literacy design principles and short animations can be used to support informed decision making about health emergencies.
引用
- Bonner C, Taba M, Fajardo MA, et al. Using health literacy principles to improve understanding of evolving evidence in health emergencies: Optimisation and evaluation of a COVID-19 vaccination risk-benefit calculator. Vaccine. 2024. PMID: 39232400. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2024.126296
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。